12 Should Your Pastor Get Rich From Preaching? (1 Timothy 5:17-6:2)

by Krisan Marotta | Nov 18, 2026 | 01 Podcasts, Timothy

What does the Bible say about paying pastors? Paul's answer in 1 Timothy 5:17-6:2 also covers accusations against leaders and living in an unjust world.

Paul's instructions in 1 Timothy 5:17-6:2 address three situations that sound ancient but feel surprisingly current:

  • how a church should support its leaders financially,
  • how it should handle accusations against respected elders, and
  • how believers should conduct themselves even inside unjust social structures.

The thread running through all three is the same question Paul keeps returning to: what does the gospel ask of us in our relationships with one another?

Key Takeaways:

  • Church Leaders who lead well, especially those who teach Scripture, deserve financial support from the community they serve.
  • Exorbitant pay for Bible teachers goes beyond what Paul envisions; his own example in 1 Corinthians shows that the goal is never wealth.
  • Accusations against church leaders require two or three independent witnesses before action is taken, protecting them from slander.
  • Appointing leaders too hastily is dangerous; spiritual maturity takes time to reveal itself.

We are in the final section of 1 Timothy, where Paul addresses a series of three issues he wants Timothy to handle within the believing community in Ephesus. Last week, we looked at Paul's guidelines for widows. Today we look at how the church should care for its leaders, and how believers should navigate the institution of slavery.

Paying Pastors

17Let the elders who rule well be considered worthy of double honor, especially those who labor in preaching and teaching. 18For the Scripture says, “You shall not muzzle an ox when it treads out the grain,” and, “The laborer deserves his wages.”  -- 1 Timothy 5:17-18

The word translated “elders” here is the Greek word presbuteroi, meaning an elderly person or elder. The Jews used this same term for those who helped govern the synagogue, and the early church appears to have adopted a similar structure.

Paul says the elders who lead well are worthy of double honor. The first honor is the natural respect that comes with publicly recognized leadership. The second honor, made clear by the very next verse, is financial support from the community. Paul's point is simple: if the community takes care of a leader's material needs, that leader can devote his time fully to studying and teaching.

Paul specifically singles out those who work hard at preaching and teaching as especially worthy of this support. In Timothy's day, that meant teaching the Old Testament in the light of the further revelation brought by Jesus. Timothy learned that teaching from Paul, who learned it from Jesus himself.

To support his point, Paul quotes two sources. The first is Deuteronomy 25:4: “You shall not muzzle the ox while he is threshing.” In the Old Testament, this was a literal command. You could not prevent an ox from eating some of the grain he was helping to produce. God prohibited robbing the animal of the fruit of its own labor.

But Paul applies it metaphorically to people who serve the church. The ox turns the wheel, grinds the grain, and must be allowed to eat from it. By analogy, it is wrong to benefit from the labor of a Bible teacher without allowing that teacher to benefit from your labor.

The second quote is from Jesus himself in Luke 10:7, spoken when he sent out the 72 disciples: “The laborer deserves his wages.” By calling that statement Scripture, Paul places the teaching of Jesus on the same level as the Old Testament. He treats both as binding authority.

Paul Explains More in 1 Corinthians 9

Paul quotes the same Deuteronomy passage in 1 Corinthians 9, where he gives a fuller explanation of his thinking. There he asks: is God's commandment about the ox really only about oxen? No. God gave that command because he wants his people to be a certain kind of people. He wants them to be people who are not so greedy and self-serving that they would rob a creature of the food it needs after it has worked for them.

The application is direct. It is wrong to benefit from someone's labor without letting them share in the fruit of that labor. For Bible teachers, the fruit they sow is spiritual. The material support they receive in return is the harvest they have a right to share in.

Paul goes on in 1 Corinthians 9 to say that just as those who serve in the temple eat from the temple offerings, those who proclaim the gospel should get their living by the gospel. It is not a privilege — it is a right.

Should Pastors Be Paid? Living on Support Part 1 (1 Corinthians 9:1-14)

Living on Support Part 2 (1 Corinthians 9:15-27)


What Paul Does and Does Not Endorse

Paul's view here requires some careful distinctions.

Does he think it would be wrong for a Bible teacher to teach without being compensated?

No. His own example proves it. In 1 Corinthians 9, Paul uses this very argument to explain why he chose not to take money from the Corinthians. He could have legitimately expected their support, but he declined it because he didn't want anyone to think he was selling the gospel. He considered it part of his reward to offer it free of charge.

Does he think it would be wrong for believers to receive teaching without compensating the teacher?

Again, no. When Paul offered the gospel free of charge, he had no criticism of his listeners for not paying him. There may be many legitimate reasons why someone doesn't compensate a teacher (limited resources, the teacher doesn't need it, or someone else has already provided support).

Paul's point is that compensation for Bible teachers is entirely appropriate. Think of it this way. If you were shipwrecked on a deserted island with a small group of people and one doctor, you wouldn't want that doctor spending his time foraging for food. You'd want the group to support his basic needs so he could devote his time to caring for everyone's health. The same logic applies to Bible teachers. If you value the teaching and the teacher needs support to continue, then support him.

What if a teacher abuses that support and pursues wealth?

Paul would reprimand him. In the very next chapter, Paul rebukes false teachers who see their ministry as a path to personal wealth. That should never be a teacher's goal.

A Biblical Perspective on Money,

What about teachers who receive very high salaries well above what the people they teach earn?

One could try to justify it through supply and demand: a particularly gifted teacher with a large audience might command a high market rate. But Paul would not accept that framing. He never appeals to his unique status as an apostle to justify being paid bountifully. Instead, he forgoes being paid at all, and he considers that a reward in itself. An attitude of accumulating wealth through ministry is fundamentally contrary to the posture Paul models.

Supporting a teacher can actually be a beautiful thing. Paul's letter to the Philippians shows that giving financially to a teacher you've learned from is one way of acknowledging the value of the gospel and expressing gratitude to God for what you've received.

11 How to Handle Idleness, Work, and Generosity,

Slander and Accountability

19Do not admit a charge against an elder except on the evidence of two or three witnesses. 20As for those who persist in sin, rebuke them in the presence of all, so that the rest may stand in fear.  -- 1 Timothy 5:19-20

Paul now turns to accountability. Leaders must be held to a standard consistent with the gospel. But they also must be protected from unjust accusations.

When someone holds a position of authority or is widely respected, others can grow jealous. Jealousy can tempt people to bring that person down through slander, making accusations that are simply false.

Paul wants Timothy to avoid two opposite errors. He must not dismiss a charge simply because the accused is a respected leader, unable to imagine that person doing wrong. But he must also not accept every accusation at face value simply because someone made it.

The safeguard is the same one the Old Testament used: require the testimony of two or three independent witnesses. One isolated accusation does not give Timothy enough to work with. But independent verification changes the situation. When wrongdoing is confirmed, the leader must be rebuked — and the rebuke must be public, so that other leaders take the warning seriously and hold themselves to the same standard.

The Danger of Favoritism

21In the presence of God and of Christ Jesus and of the elect angels I charge you to keep these rules without prejudging, doing nothing from partiality. 22Do not be hasty in the laying on of hands, nor take part in the sins of others; keep yourself pure. 23(No longer drink only water, but use a little wine for the sake of your stomach and your frequent ailments.) 24The sins of some people are conspicuous, going before them to judgment, but the sins of others appear later. 25So also good works are conspicuous, and even those that are not cannot remain hidden.  -- 1 Timothy 5:21-25

Paul presses the point with a solemn charge. Timothy appointed these leaders. They are his co-workers. Over time, they will likely become his friends. And friendship creates a natural temptation toward favoritism.

Think of a coach who has a rule for every player on the team. When another child breaks the rule, the coach enforces the consequence without hesitation. When his own child breaks the same rule, he starts making excuses: the child was tired, it wasn't that serious, the other player started it. The rule hasn't changed. The facts haven't changed. What changed is the relationship between the coach and the person who broke the rule.

That is exactly the danger Paul is warning about. Favoritism violates the very heart of the gospel. The leader who is Timothy's friend is still a sinner like everyone else. No leader is above correction. Every one of them is capable of any sin. Timothy must view them as fellow sinners and refuse to give them preferential treatment when it comes to accountability.

When Timothy appoints a new elder, he performs a laying-on-of-hands ceremony. Paul's instruction: do not rush it. Give a potential leader time to reveal who they actually are before you put them in that role.

The reason is sobering. If you appoint someone too quickly and they later fall into sin, you share some of the blame. You appointed them before they were ready. So take your time, watch them over a period of time, and let their character reveal itself.

Paul adds a practical observation about why this matters. Some people's weaknesses are immediately obvious. Their immaturity is plain to see, and you wouldn't consider them for leadership. But others look very good on the surface.

Think of a job interview where someone says all the right things, presents well, and seems perfectly suited for the role. Six months later, you discover they can't handle criticism, won't take responsibility for mistakes, and fall apart under pressure. None of that was visible in the interview. You needed to watch them handle real responsibility over time.

Spiritual maturity is the same. A person may know all the right answers about Christianity and still lack the character that leadership demands. Give it time. The truth will emerge.

Paul also inserts a brief personal aside here — a note to Timothy about his chronic digestive troubles, suggesting that a little wine might help. It has nothing to do with the surrounding argument; Paul himself seems to have remembered something he wanted to pass along and dropped it in before he forgot. It is a small but genuinely human moment in an otherwise weighty letter.

My Solution to the Great Pastor Resignation,

Slaves, Masters, and the Gospel's Reputation

6:1Let all who are under a yoke as bondservants regard their own masters as worthy of all honor, so that the name of God and the teaching may not be reviled. 2Those who have believing masters must not be disrespectful on the ground that they are brothers; rather they must serve all the better since those who benefit by their good service are believers and beloved. Teach and urge these things.  -- 1 Timothy 6:1-2

Paul briefly turns to a third issue: how the church should handle believers who are slaves and believers who are slave owners.

His instruction to believing slaves is to regard their masters as worthy of honor. And if the master is also a believer, the slave should be even more respectful, not less. Paul's primary concern is the reputation of the gospel among outsiders.

Slavery was woven into the fabric of Roman society. If believing slaves began mistreating or defying their masters, it would be read as revolutionary, as an attempt to subvert Roman culture. That perception would cause people to fear and reject the gospel as a destabilizing threat.

Paul's perspective is not that slavery is morally acceptable. He clearly sees it as a problem. But he does not believe that eliminating any specific human institution is the goal of the gospel. Human beings are sinful and they build sinful cultures. Pouring all of one's energy into overthrowing one particular evil does not change the hearts that produce that evil.

What does change hearts is the gospel itself. And as the gospel spreads and more people come to believe it, the cultural and social structures that depend on dehumanization begin to lose their footing. That is exactly what happened with slavery over time. Its social legitimacy eroded not primarily through revolution but through the advance of the gospel. As more people in the Roman empire became Christians, slavery became increasingly incompatible with the worldview those Christians held. The gospel did eventually bring an end to slavery, but it did so by transforming individuals from the inside.

So Paul tells believing slaves: your mission is not to free yourself or topple Roman institutions. Your mission is to live faithfully as a follower of Jesus in whatever situation you find yourself. And if both you and your master are believers, then serve him all the more. Not because the social arrangement demands it, but because he is your brother. Serve him out of love for God.

Philemon: How to be a Hero

The Common Thread

On the surface, these three issues ( widows, elders, and slaves) seem unrelated. But there is a single thread running through all of them.

Paul wants believers to think differently about every relationship they are in.

Instead of asking what someone owes them, or what they are entitled to, or how they can make sure they are treated fairly, he wants them to ask what the gospel teaches about how to treat this particular person.

If someone has served you well, be willing to support them. If someone holds a position of leadership, respect them without pretending they are above correction. If you find yourself in a difficult or unjust situation, consider how your conduct reflects on the gospel you claim to believe.

Paul is not trying to create a community where everyone has the same role. He is trying to create a community where everyone is learning to live as someone who belongs to Jesus Christ — whether they are rich or poor, leader or servant, owner or owned.

That is the question for us. Are we treating the people around us based on what we can get from them, what they owe us, or how much influence they have? Or are we treating them as people who matter to God?

The gospel is supposed to change more than our theology. It is supposed to change how we treat one another. And Paul has given us some very concrete, real-world examples of what that change looks like.

Please listen to the podcast for more detail and explanation.

Next: 13 What Does Godliness With Contentment Mean? (1 Timothy 6:3–11)

Previous: 11 What the Bible Says About Caring for Aging Parents (1 Timothy 5:3-16)

Series: 1 Timothy: Fight the Good Fight

Resources to help you study: 1 Timothy

Photo by Krisan Marotta

Season 28, Episode 12

Page Views: 1