11 Why Trying Harder Can’t Make You Holy (Romans 8:1-11)

by Krisan Marotta | Jul 24, 2013 | 01 Podcasts, Romans

Updated November 2026

Romans 7 ends with a cry: "Wretched man that I am, who will save me from this body of death?" Romans 8:1–11 is the answer. Left to ourselves, we have no resources to become holy. But God has done what the law could not do. He has given us his Spirit, the same power that raised Jesus from the dead.

Key Takeaways

  • The moral paralysis Paul describes in Romans 7 — wanting to do good but being unable — is the problem Romans 8 answers.
  • Left to ourselves, we have no resources to become holy. The Spirit of God is the only source of that change.
  • "In the flesh" and "in the Spirit" describe a believer's status before God, not a moment-by-moment feeling or technique.
  • Walking by the Spirit cannot be manufactured. The moment you try to produce it yourself, you are trusting your own effort, not God's.
  • Obedience is now possible for believers in a way it never was before, and it is guaranteed in the age to come.
  • The same power that raised Jesus from the dead is now available to believers through the indwelling Spirit.

The Image From Psalm 1

Before we get to Romans, I want to take you to Psalm 1, because it gives a metaphor that I think captures what's going on in our passage.

Blessed is the man who walks not in the counsel of the wicked, nor stands in the way of sinners, nor sits in the seat of scoffers. But his delight is in the law of the Lord, and on his law he meditates day and night. He is like a tree planted by streams of water that yields its fruit in its season, and its leaf does not wither, and in all that he does, he prospers.

That image of trees planted by streams of water is what I want you to keep in mind as we study Romans 8, because that's essentially what Paul is going to talk about. Notice the progression in the Psalm. First you delight. You want to do the law. Then you meditate on it. It becomes part of your life and a priority. Then you see the fruit, you see changes happening. Paul's argument in Romans 8 is that it is the Spirit of God who accomplishes these things in us, who brings about this deep, eternal change.

Romans Review

Romans 1-5 argue that we are justified by faith, and by faith alone. At the end of chapter 3, Paul announces that there is a way to be justified: by faith in Jesus. In chapter 5 he says, so what? Now that we've been justified by faith, what does that mean? He argues it gives us a reason to rejoice, because we have been singled out by God to be made holy and glorious, and our hope is guaranteed because God loves us and the promise is up to him to keep.

In Romans 6, he starts addressing objections to the gospel. The first objection was that Paul's gospel implies we should sin more in order to glorify God. Paul says no, because part of the gift of grace is setting us free from sin. The second objection was that even if we shouldn't pursue sin, there's no reason not to because now there's no punishment. Paul says there is still a reason not to sin, and that's death — the decay, the brokenness, the fallenness, the corruption of life. He adds that the law was no incentive anyway, because the law forced us to rely on ourselves, and all we had was more sin. The law didn't make us better people. It showed us how sinful we are.

Then there's a follow-up: if the law just promotes sinfulness, it must be an evil thing. Paul says no, the law is good because it taught us the truth. It alerted us that we're sinful and that we need a savior.

That takes us through chapter 7, where Paul describes what I'm going to call moral paralysis. He says we have this problem: I want to be good, and I lack the ability to be good. I agree with the law, I want to keep the law, I desire to keep it — and yet I can't. I find myself doing the very thing I don't want to do. I'm trapped in my sinfulness. Whatever I thought would control my sin — willpower, resolve, determination — it didn't work.

The Central Argument of Romans 8

Paul ends chapter 7 with "Wretched man that I am, who will save me from this body of death?"

Chapter 8 answers that question. All of chapter 8 explains why faith in Jesus is the solution to that problem. Paul is going to argue there is a way out of that moral paralysis, and it's faith in Jesus. He's going to explain why that works when obedience to the law didn't work.

I have to warn you, it's hard to break this chapter up. My breaks are rather arbitrary because it's really one flow of thought. So when you study it, read the whole chapter. Here's the argument in brief.

First, left to yourself, you can't make yourself holy. Paul calls that your flesh. Left to your flesh, you are stuck. You do not have the resources to bring about moral obedience or to make yourself holy. We learned why in chapter 1. God, in his wrath, abandoned us to our sin and death. When we rebelled and turned our backs on God, in his wrath he turned his back on us and withdrew life. He is the only source of holiness and life and goodness, and he's not offering it. All we have is sinfulness.

So the only way to become holy is for God to make you holy.

The unbeliever lacks the Spirit of God and thus has no possibility of being holy. But once Jesus solves the problem of God's wrath and God can turn back to us and draw us to him, he gives us his Spirit. That gives us the resources to become holy. The resources of God are available to the believer in a way they were not available before, when you were under the law or under wrath.

Without the Spirit, we have no hope of becoming holy. With the Spirit, we have a guaranteed hope of becoming holy.

Paul's going to argue through this chapter that there is a direct correspondence. The more we genuinely trust in the Spirit of God to make us holy, the more obedience we will see. The more we trust in ourselves to make ourselves holy, the more sinfulness we will see and experience. You trust in God, you will get obedience. You trust in yourself, you will get sin and death.

But be very careful with that, because Paul is also going to argue that this trust is part of the gift. My trusting Jesus is not something I manufacture or muster up or accomplish through the right technique. Paul is going to argue that this is a process God takes us through step by step, day by day, of maturing. Every day moves us closer to that goal, but it's not something we manufacture. There's no five-step plan to becoming a more faithful person, no twelve steps to obedience. It's up to God to strengthen our faith.

Remember chapter 5: your hope will not disappoint because God loves you and it's up to him to get you there and give you your inheritance.

So while obedience is not guaranteed at any given moment, it is now possible in a way it was never possible before for believers. It is guaranteed in the age to come because of the Spirit of God. We've solved the problem of our moral paralysis because now we have the Spirit of God, and that makes obedience possible in a way that was never possible before.

Defining "In the Flesh" and "In the Spirit"

You'll see the phrases "in the flesh" and "in the Spirit" coming up a lot. When Paul says "in the flesh," he means everything I am apart from God, self-reliance. This is not a moment-by-moment situation. This is who I am. I am either a child of God or I'm not. By definition, someone who is "in the flesh" is an unbeliever. So Paul is not talking about our physical body, not talking about worldliness or misplaced desires. He's talking about the me who is apart from God, the me who is depending only on myself. Everything I am apart from God.

"In the Spirit," on the other hand, is someone who has the resources of God available to them. Again, I think that's my identity, my status. Am I justified or not? Am I forgiven or not? Someone "in the Spirit" is by definition a believer.

Now, this is different from the phrases "walking in the Spirit," "being in the Spirit," or "having a mindset on the Spirit." When Paul uses those phrases, I think he is talking about the moment-by-moment choice. In any given moment, am I living as if I am trusting in the Spirit of God or not? My status hasn't changed. I am a believer if I have the Spirit of God, and I can't lose that. But I can live as if it's not true, or I can live as if it is.

So "having a mindset on the Spirit" or "walking according to the Spirit" refers not to my ultimate destiny, but to what's the object of my trust at this particular moment. Am I trusting in myself to bring about righteousness, or am I trusting in God's Spirit to bring it about for me? If I'm trusting in myself, I'm walking in the flesh. If I'm trusting in God, I have my mind set on the Spirit.

The believer has the option of doing either one. The unbeliever does not. The unbeliever can only rely on themselves.

You Cannot Walk by the Spirit Through the Flesh

This is probably the most important thing I'm ever going to say. If you learn nothing else from Romans, please learn this: You cannot walk according to the Spirit by the flesh.

We hear there's a one-to-one correspondence between obedience and faith, and we think: great. The more faith I have, the more obedience I have. I want to be obedient. So what does it look like? What does it feel like? How do I know at any given moment whether I'm walking by the Spirit or not? Do I have to have a certain feeling, a certain attitude? Do I pray enough or study enough?

It's a legitimate question. I would bet that everyone in this room came to faith because they got sick and tired of the sin and death in their lives. So it's a great relief to hear that obedience is possible and it depends on faith. But the minute I try to do it, I am doing it, and I am now in the flesh.

The harder I try to make sure that I am walking in the Spirit, the less I am actually walking in the Spirit. The minute you try to study enough or read enough or memorize enough or pray enough or feel a certain way — if it's something I do, I'm doing it, and it's my flesh. It's not the Spirit of God.

I was taught as a new believer that walking according to the Spirit was the key to moral obedience, and all I had to do was walk by the Spirit, set my mind on the Spirit, and I would be obedient. I spent I don't know how many years trying to accomplish just that. I had my formula. I would spend great mental energy trying to figure out: am I in the Spirit now or not? Do I have the right keys?

If Paul walked in and heard me wrestling with that dilemma, I think he would laugh at me. Because it is true that the Spirit is the key to moral obedience but I do not hold that key in my hands. That key is in God's hands. It's up to him to get me there. It's not something I do for myself. It's part of the gift. And that is amazingly comforting, because it means I can't mess it up, I can't lose it, I can't slow it down, I can't get God off his plan, and I can't mess up my salvation.

I had a certain feeling I thought meant I was in the Spirit. It was a kind of combination of humility and smallness. If I got myself into that state, I thought I was walking by the Spirit. I had a visual image of filling up a jar in the sink. When I got it all filled up, I had this feeling and knew I was in the Spirit. But I had a leak somewhere, because it would all go away again. I spent years wrestling with this. And I think that had everything to do with the flesh and nothing to do with the Spirit, because anyone can psych themselves into feeling a certain way.

Where does Paul ever say that walking by the Spirit is something you feel? I don't think it's there. He's going to argue later in chapter 8 that we know we're in the Spirit if we're grieving over our sins and we long to be holy, but those aren't something we muster up.

Walking by the Spirit is an intangible, invisible reality beyond my control, beyond my ability to manipulate or conjure. It's totally in the hands of God. It's a gift, which means it's guaranteed. It's a promise. Remember chapter 4: I can't earn it, because if I earned it, it would be a wage, not a gift. And in chapter 5, hope does not disappoint. We will get our inheritance because it's up to God and he loves us enough to get us there.

Also remember the purpose. Paul is trying to answer the question: how does faith in Jesus do what the law could not do? He's not here to give us a magic formula or a practical technique for victory over sin tomorrow night. His answer is: you have the Spirit of God at work in your life, and you didn't before. The law made no provision to give you the Spirit of God, but grace does. And the Spirit of God is going to solve that problem.

That is completely good news. It means we can have absolute confidence that no matter what we face tomorrow, it's in God's hands and he's going to bring good about.

Condemnation (Romans 8:1-4)

There is therefore now no condemnation for those who are in Christ Jesus. For the law of the Spirit of life has set you free in Christ Jesus from the law of sin and death. Romans 8:1-2

I used to think "condemnation" here meant eternal judgment. I think Paul has something closer to context in mind. You are not condemned to stay in that spot described in chapter 7. You are not condemned to the moral paralysis of being trapped in your sins.

Why? Because the law of the Spirit of life has set you free in Christ Jesus from the law of sin and death. Because grace gives us access to the Spirit of God, it sets us free from that bondage to sin and death. Grace works because the law had no provision for giving you the Spirit, and the gospel does. That is the difference between law and grace. The demands of the law are such that only the resources of God himself can meet them, and we don't have that when we're under God's wrath. But because of our justification, because of what Jesus did for us on the cross, God can give us his Spirit through his boundless grace and set us free to become righteous.

For God has done what the law, weakened by the flesh, could not do. By sending his own Son in the likeness of sinful flesh for sin, he condemned sin in the flesh, in order that the righteous requirement of the law might be fulfilled in us, who walk not according to the flesh, but according to the Spirit. -- Romans 8:3-4

Left to ourselves, we could not make ourselves righteous. But God did what we couldn't do, what the law couldn't make us do. He sent his Son to die for us, to take the penalty for our sin, to satisfy his justice — in order that the law might be fulfilled in us. In order that we might become people who are now holy, who can walk not according to the flesh, not trusting in ourselves, but trusting in him.

"The righteous requirement of the law" is simply the moral demands, the kind of righteousness described and prescribed by the law. Those who walk not according to the flesh but according to the Spirit are people who are learning day by day to trust more and more in God — to trust him to make them holy rather than doing it on their own.

Life in the Spirit (Romans 8:5-8)

5 For those who live according to the flesh set their minds on the things of the flesh, but those who live according to the Spirit set their minds on the things of the Spirit. 6 For to set the mind on the flesh is death, but to set the mind on the Spirit is life and peace. 7 For the mind that is set on the flesh is hostile to God, for it does not submit to God's law; indeed, it cannot. 8 Those who are in the flesh cannot please God.

Paul is saying: if you're trying to gain holiness through your own effort, all you're going to get is death. If you're trying to gain holiness by trusting God, life and peace will result. In verses 7 and 8, he argues that if you're not trusting in God, you don't even have the possibility of being holy, because you don't have the Spirit of God. The mindset on the flesh is death. The mindset on the Spirit is life and peace.

I understand that peace in the Hebrew sense — shalom — which is a very hard word to describe, but it carries the idea of wholeness, completeness, contentment, worthwhile living. It would be the opposite of the brokenness and death described earlier.

The Power That Raised Jesus in You (Romans 8:9-11)

Then this — this is the best part. Verses 9 through 11:

You, however, are not in the flesh, but in the Spirit, if in fact the Spirit of God dwells in you. Anyone who does not have the Spirit of God does not belong to him.

Paul is saying: you're not like that. You have something unbelievers don't have. If you are a believer, you have the Spirit of God. And if you have that, you have everything. Because that's the seal, the down payment, the guarantee that you will become holy.

But if Christ is in you, although the body is dead because of sin, the Spirit is life because of righteousness.

If Christ is in you through the indwelling of the Holy Spirit, then although you yourself have no resources to become holy — that's what I think he means by "the body is dead because of sin," under wrath you don't have the option of being holy — the Spirit is life. Because of righteousness, because of your right standing before God, because you are justified, because you have been forgiven by the blood of Jesus, you now have a resource you didn't have before. That resource is the Spirit of God to make you holy.

If the Spirit of him who raised Jesus from the dead dwells in you, he who raised Christ Jesus from the dead will also give life to your mortal bodies through his Spirit who dwells in you.

That's the best news. The power of God that raised Jesus from the dead is now available to you. If he could take Jesus, who was completely and physically dead, and raise him to newness of life, don't you think he can bring you out of your bondage to sin and into holiness through his Spirit who dwells in you?

Left to ourselves, we'd be trapped in the moral paralysis of chapter 7, unable to become holy. But now, as believers, we have the Spirit of God available to us. God is committed, because of his grace, to see to it that we who couldn't obey the law even when we wanted to now have the resources to do it.

It doesn't mean you're going to be perfect every moment of every day. It means you're going to get to the finish line and you're going to win the race. Tomorrow may be hard, and the day after that may be harder, but you're going to get there. You are not stuck in the dilemma of chapter 7. You have the chance and the guaranteed hope.

Back to Psalm 1

Let me take you back to Psalm 1 to remind you of that image:

His delight is in the law of the Lord, and on his law he meditates day and night. He is like a tree planted by streams of water that yields its fruit in its season, and its leaf does not wither, and all that he does, he prospers.

That's the image. We are now planted into the Holy Spirit, if you will. God is making our roots run down deep so that we have this everlasting source of life and goodness and holiness. And he gives it to us freely as an act of grace and compassion because of the blood of Jesus Christ.

That's incredibly good news, because it means you don't have to fear that you're going to be trapped in sin forever. Even now God is working in you to change you, to nourish you, to make you more and more someone who trusts him.

He never promises this is an instant, overnight change. In fact, he promises the opposite — it's going to be a long road, and it's going to involve suffering. But you will get there. And Paul is going to go on in this chapter to say it's worth it. If we could get just a little glimpse of the kind of people we will be and what heaven will be like, we would look at all of this and say, "I'd do it again." He uses the phrase that it's not even worth comparing. What we're getting versus what we go through now — as hard as it is — it's not even a comparison.

Next: 12 Why Faith Works When the Law Doesn't (Romans 8:12-25)

Previous: 10 Why You Can't Stop Doing What You Hate (Romans 7:7-25)

Series: Romans: Justification by Faith

Study: Romans Resources

AI-generated image created by the author.

Season 2, Episode 11

Page Views: 1,584