Updated November 2026
Is it fair for God to have mercy on Moses and harden Pharaoh? How can he still find fault if no one can resist his will? In Romans 9:14–33, Paul takes those questions head-on and gives four answers. When you argue with God, you are not arguing with an equal, and the real wonder is not that some are lost but that any of us are saved.
Key Takeaways
- A debate with God is not a discussion between equals. There is no standard above God to which he must answer, and the one who changes in the debate is us.
- The ultimate reason for God's choice is that God chose. Salvation depends not on human will or exertion but on God who has mercy.
- God's sovereignty is not tyranny. He is not fallen, and his sovereignty is a blessing to us.
- Paul gives four answers to "Why does he still find fault?": who are we to answer back, the potter's right over the clay, God's purposes we cannot see, and the fact that without his intervention all of us would be lost.
- You know whether someone is saved by how they respond to Jesus, the stumbling stone in Zion.
- If you are asking "Am I saved?", that desire is itself a sign God is at work in you.
The Soccer Coach Who Changed the Rules
My daughter plays on a travel soccer team, and I like to tell stories about her soccer adventures because she's really good and it's fun.
Around U13, her coach stopped playing all the players equally during the games. He had a mini rebellion on his hands. Some of the players and some of the parents started voicing their accusations that he was being unfair because he didn't treat everyone exactly the same, he didn't hand out the same rewards to people, players who missed practice didn't play as much as those who had been there, and some players he worked on certain skills a lot harder than others.
After one of the games, some parents confronted him. He very calmly listened to all their complaints, and then he said, "Well, everything you said is true, but this is soccer. You're not describing injustice, you're describing soccer. This isn't U9 anymore." He basically asserted that he is the coach, he has the right to make his own judgments, and that players under his authority are exactly that. They are under his authority. They are players, not equals.
That's essentially what's going on in Romans 9. In a sense, Paul is debating with God, and the thing to remember is that when you debate with God, it is not a discussion between equals. Like a coach and his players, a discussion with God is one where he has authority and we don't.
There's another difference worth naming. In a debate between you and me, we would appeal to the Bible as the authority. With God, there is nothing to appeal to above him. God is the standard. There is no standard of justice above God to which God should be held. And debates with God generally change us, not God. He doesn't need philosophical discussions with us. He does invite us to speak to him and to learn from him and to listen. But in the long run, the one who is going to change in the debate is us. He doesn't need information from us. He doesn't need answers from us.
We also can't fit God into our theological box. Part of the problem when you hit a chapter like Romans 9 is that we've grown up thinking of God as a safe, comfortable, easy-to-understand presence who answers all our prayers and gives us what we want. We fit him into a comfortable little box that we've made for him. Then we hit a passage like Romans 9, which forces us to break through all those walls, and we just have to realize that God is bigger than any theological box we design.
Romans Review
In the first eight chapters, Paul gives his argument that we are justified by grace on the basis of faith in Jesus Christ, and that alone. That raises a question at the end of that section. Is the gospel too good to be true? Is it such good news that how could it possibly be that good?
That's really what Paul is answering now, and the way he's answering it is by asking us to look at how God dealt with Israel. If God set the Israelites apart and made them his people and chose them and called them, and they turned against him and rejected him in large numbers, then how do we know he's trustworthy? How do we know that he has called us and that we won't fall away? The underlying question is whether the gospel is too good to be true, and the way Paul answers it is by showing how God dealt with Israel. If he was trustworthy with Israel, then we know he will be trustworthy with us. Chapters 9 through 11 are all one unit built around that theme.
The second principle Paul draws out is that salvation is always based on divine promise. God himself promises to act, and he acts. He promises to save some, and he does. The first principle was that salvation is never based on natural advantages, not ancestry, not privilege, not opportunity. That was the point in the section about Abraham and Sarah, where the birth of Isaac was a biological miracle, partly to make the point that it is God who brings about salvation.
The third point, which is probably the hardest for us to deal with, is that God's choice is not based on the behavior of individuals. Paul looks at Jacob and Esau, who were twins of the same father, and before they were even born and had done anything either good or bad, God declared that Jacob he loved and Esau he hated. Salvation is based on God's promise, not on human works, not on something we've done to earn it. And remember, part of Paul's point was that we are not born neutral. Jacob and Esau, and none of us, were born in a neutral state from which we then chose to go this way or that way. Paul's point is that we are all born lost, we are all born broken, and God will save some of us.
The Central Question: Is God Fair?
So that raises the question. If it's not natural advantage, what is it? How does God choose?
Paul answers that in this section, starting in verse 14. This is a hard section, but it's a wonderful one because we're going to get answers to questions I've always wanted answered. Is it fair? He deals with that directly. Is it fair for God to save Moses and not Pharaoh, or to save me and not my brother? He's going to deal with that head-on. And he's going to answer the question of how God can blame us if we're born sinful and can't do anything about it. Paul gives four answers to that question. I was genuinely happy to find this, because I've read all these books and papers where people wrestle with these questions, and no one ever looked at Romans 9. We have an answer. We have four of them.
Let's start in verse 14. "What shall we say then? Is there injustice on God's part?" He's setting up the problem. Jacob loved, Esau hated. God chose one and passed over the other. Is that fair?
"For he says to Moses, 'I will have mercy on whom I have mercy, and I will have compassion on whom I have compassion.' So then it depends not on human will or exertion, but on God who has mercy. For the scripture says to Pharaoh, 'For this very purpose I have raised you up, that I might show my power in you, and that my name might be proclaimed in all the earth.' So then he has mercy on whomever he wills, and he hardens whomever he wills."
The main point here is that the ultimate reason for God's choice is that God chose. Verse 16 makes it plain: salvation is not based on human effort or human will. It's based on God who has mercy. That's hard to grasp. We may not like it. But it's pretty clear what it says.
It makes us face the fact that God is sovereign and that he is not responsible to anyone or answering to anyone. Part of the reason we have trouble with that is because we connect sovereignty with tyranny. To give any person we know that kind of absolute power would destroy us. We've fought against that in our family lives, in national life, in government. We set up checks and balances precisely because we believe one person should not have that kind of absolute power, because they will abuse it.
So we come to God and we think, how can he have that kind of absolute sovereignty? But God is not like us. God is not fallen. God is not sinful. And what you have to come back to is this: if God had to answer to anyone, if there were some standard or being above God to which he must answer, then he is not really God. The very nature of God is that he is sovereign. He does what he pleases. What we have to get rid of is the idea that his sovereignty is destructive to us or dangerous. As we've seen through Romans 1 through 8, it is not. It is a blessing.
Moses, Pharaoh, and What Their Stories Prove
It's interesting that Paul picks Moses and Pharaoh as his examples here.
Moses is probably one of the greatest exemplars of the faith. He is called the friend of God, said to have been the meekest man on the face of the earth. His humility, his gentleness, his godliness are all commended in Scripture. By contrast, Pharaoh is among the worst. He was vile and cruel. Human life meant nothing to him. He exploited an entire nation for his economic prosperity and killed rivals without hesitation.
The quote Paul uses, "I will have mercy on whom I have mercy and compassion on whom I have compassion," comes from Exodus 33, one of the high points of Moses' life. Moses is in the tent where God meets him. The cloud comes down and settles on the tent. The people are standing outside with their jaws on the ground, amazed that Moses has just walked into this tent and that the glory of God has settled down on it. And it says that God spoke to Moses as a man would speak to his friend.
In that remarkable moment, God says, "I will have mercy on whom I have mercy." What is he saying? Don't conclude that there's something so special about Moses that God would treat him this way. Even at our best, it is still God's choice. The best you have to offer is not enough to require God to save you. None of us are worthy to approach God. We receive his mercy because he is merciful and compassionate.
Now, in contrast, here is Pharaoh, one of the worst. But Paul doesn't say God rejected Pharaoh because he was evil. He says God had a plan, a purpose, a reason beyond Pharaoh himself. He did it that he might be glorified. When the Exodus took place, it was such a miracle that word of it spread throughout the ancient world. While Israel wandered in the wilderness, the people of Canaan were terrified of them because they'd heard about the crossing of the Red Sea. Hundreds of years later, the Philistines in 1 Samuel 4 are still afraid of the Israelites because of what their God did at the Red Sea. Paul's point is that God hardened Pharaoh in order to do something glorious, so that his name might be proclaimed throughout the world.
Neither Moses nor Pharaoh deserved anything but condemnation. Moses at his best was not required to be saved. Pharaoh at his worst was simply an example of unredeemed humanity.
Verse 16 sums it up. It does not depend on man's desire or effort, but on God who has mercy.
Four Answers to a Hard Objection
Now Paul takes up the next question, and it's the one that feels most viscerally unfair.
"You will say to me then, 'Why does he still find fault? For who can resist his will?'"
That is our gut reaction. If it doesn't depend on us, if we're born this way and we can't change ourselves, why does God still say we're to blame? It's the same question that surfaces in every form: if God is sovereign, why is there evil in the world? If God is sovereign, why does he let good people suffer? All the same question.
Paul gives four answers.
First answer: Who are we to answer back?
"But who are you, O man, to answer back to God? Will what is molded say to its molder, 'Why have you made me like this?'"
Before answering the question, Paul examines our credentials. Consider the difference between man and God. We are finite. Our knowledge is limited, our strength is limited, our vision is limited. The Bible tells us our lives are like a breath or a puff of air compared to eternity. Even our best plans sometimes end in disaster. We demonstrate over and over again, on the grand scale and the small scale, that we are capable of profound foolishness. Even when you're genuinely trying to do the right thing, you can end up hurting someone. You didn't mean to. You had the best intentions. And yet even in little situations we make those mistakes.
Now set that alongside God, who is infinite in knowledge, infinite in power, infinite in wisdom, all-knowing, knowing everything from beginning to end. Are we really qualified to bring charges? There are mysteries we do not understand. There are objectives we do not know, and there are forces in the universe that we are simply not equipped to reckon with.
That might sound like a cop-out, so let me point you to the book of Job, because it goes much deeper. Job was not a skeptic arguing against God. He was a devout man who loved God, and yet he was deeply bewildered by the catastrophes that came upon him. He lost his family, his wealth, his health, one disaster after another. His three friends came in and said, "Job, we know why you're suffering. You've done something sinful. Just figure out what it is, confess it, repent, and God will fix it." In his despair, Job cried out to God, not blaming him but pleading with him, saying what you're doing seems so unfair to me.
Then God answers, in chapters 38 through 41. If this troubles you, dig into that section sometime. God says, "Okay. You wanted a chance to talk to me. Here I am. But before I answer your questions, let me ask you some." And God says things like, "Where were you when I laid the foundation of the earth? Where were you when the morning stars sang together and I flung the heavens into space? Do you understand how rain works? Can you order the courses of the stars? Can you make the Pleiades shine forth? Can you make Orion stride across the sky?" It goes on and on. And at the end, Job falls on his face before God and says, essentially, I didn't know what I was getting into when I asked these questions. You are not in my league at all. And he repents.
That's the force of Paul's first argument. Who are we to judge God and say he's not being fair when we don't understand even a tiny fraction of what must be known to answer those questions?
Second answer: God has the right of a potter over clay.
"Has the potter no right over the clay, to make out of the same lump one vessel for honored use and another for dishonored use?"
A potter sits at his wheel, takes one lump of clay, divides it in half, and makes a beautiful vase out of one half and a slop jar out of the other. And that's fine. We don't question his right to do that. Men exercise that kind of authority regularly. So why would we question God's sovereignty?
You might say, hold on, we're not clay. We have feelings, emotions, wills, self-awareness. The analogy doesn't hold. But think about how we treat plants and animals. A gardener has the right to rip out whatever plants he wants and put new ones in. A farmer has the right to decide which cattle go to slaughter and which go to breeding. When a fly comes into your kitchen, you swat it without a second thought. We have that kind of delegated authority over the living world. God gave us dominion in Genesis 1 and 2, and part of that dominion includes making those choices.
Paul's argument is that God has that same authority over us. There are parts of the Old Testament where God compares us to grasshoppers. And the point, at least in Isaiah, is not to diminish us but to magnify this truth: he cares for us. How remarkable is that.
Third answer: God has purposes we cannot see.
"What if God, desiring to show his wrath and to make known his power, has endured with much patience vessels of wrath prepared for destruction, in order to make known the riches of his glory for the vessels of mercy which he prepared beforehand for glory, even us whom he has called, not from the Jews only, but also from the Gentiles?"
What if God has purposes and objectives that we simply don't see? What if one of those purposes was to display his power and his mercy by enduring, with extraordinary patience, centuries of people who blasphemed him, talked against him, and claimed that he was dead, and then in response to all of that, he still saved some? What if his patience and long-suffering are themselves part of the lesson he is teaching us about his character?
Paul also seems to imply something harder here, something I want to offer as speculation rather than certainty: what if some must be lost in order for some to be saved? What if it takes the display of God's wrath placed alongside his patience in order to bring any of us to salvation? I'd want to confirm that interpretation elsewhere in Scripture before pressing it too hard, but it does seem to be implied.
Paul goes further. He seems to suggest that no Gentiles would ever have been saved unless Israel had turned away, and that only a remnant of Israel was saved. For most of us, who are probably not of Jewish ancestry, that is a profound blessing. The people who never had the advantages Israel had, who never had the prophets and the privileges, were drawn in because of Israel's turning away. And Paul quotes both Isaiah and Hosea as predicting exactly that.
Fourth answer: Without God's intervention, all of us would be lost.
"As Isaiah predicted, 'If the Lord of hosts had not left us offspring, we would have been like Sodom and become like Gomorrah.'"
If God had not chosen to draw a remnant to himself, every one of us would have gone the way of Sodom and Gomorrah. That's his final argument. We start from the wrong premise. We start thinking that everyone ought to be saved, so we ask why God is condemning a few. But the real answer is that everyone ought to be condemned, and God is saving a few. We're all born lost. Remember chapter 3, where Paul says there is not one who does good, not even one, none who seeks after God. Without God's grace reaching out to us, we would all be lost. The whole race would be.
The Stumbling Stone
Paul closes with a remarkable paragraph, and I think people are essentially asking: how can you tell if anyone is saved? If you can't tell by their Jewish heritage, if you can't tell by their choices, how do you look at someone and know? How do you look at yourself and know?
That's what Paul answers in verses 30 to the end.
"What shall we say then? That Gentiles who did not pursue righteousness have attained it, that is, a righteousness that is by faith. But Israel who pursued a law that would lead to righteousness did not succeed in reaching that law. Why? Because they did not pursue it by faith, but as if it were based on works. They have stumbled over the stumbling stone, as it is written, 'Behold, I am laying in Zion a stone of stumbling, and a rock of offense, and whoever believes in him will not be put to shame.'"
The force of that paragraph is this: you know whether someone is saved by how they respond to Jesus. That's the stumbling stone in Zion. If you're wondering whether God has drawn you to him, if you're looking at someone else's life and wondering whether they've been saved, the question to ask is: how do they answer the question of who Jesus is and what he did?
The image is of a path with a large flat rock in the middle. You can either fall over it or stand on it. People trip over Jesus when they reject him. People stand on him and gain life and will never be put to shame. The Jews who were determined to work out their salvation on the basis of their own behavior and their own good works stumbled over that stone. They rejected Jesus because they wouldn't admit they needed a savior. But for those who saw the standard, knew they couldn't reach it, and said, I need someone to rescue me, that desire is itself evidence that the Spirit of God has already been at work.
The fact that you're even asking the question, am I saved? is a good sign. It means you want to be saved. And Paul's argument is that God must have put that desire in your heart. If you weren't asking the question, it's because God is at work in you. Without him, Paul says, we would be like Sodom and Gomorrah. We wouldn't care. We wouldn't want to be saved. We wouldn't even ask whether God loves us.
The crisis point for every human being is the same question. Who is Jesus Christ, and what did he do for you? You can be very religious. You can spend a lifetime pursuing religious activities. But if you haven't answered that question, you've missed the point of faith altogether. God placed Jesus in the midst of human history to reveal those whom he has called.
Jesus himself said it plainly in John 6: "No one can come to me except the Father who sent me draw him." And also in that same passage: "All that my Father has given me will come to me, and whoever comes to me I will never cast out."
What This Means for Us
Paul has essentially told us that God is not a tame lion. He is bigger than we think. He is sovereign in ways we can't fully imagine. We are not qualified to answer the questions we most want answered, because we don't have the understanding he has. But what we do need, and what we can handle, is to know who Jesus is. That we can figure out. That we can come to.
So the response to a passage like this is simply to say thank you. Thank you that you called me. Thank you that you drew me. Thank you that you did not leave me in my lostness.
Next: 16 Why Sincere Religion Can Miss the Point (Romans 10)
Previous: 14 Is the Gospel Too Good to Be True? (Romans 9:1-13)
Series: Romans: Justification by Faith
Study: Romans Resources
AI-generated image created by the author.
Season 2, Episode 15
Page Views: 1,377
