21 When Christians Disagree (Romans 14:1-20)

by Krisan Marotta | May 23, 2018 | 01 Podcasts, Romans

Updated November 2026

What do sincere Christians do when another believer is doing something they find questionable? And what do you do when you're the one being questioned? In Romans 14, Paul takes on what I call our favorite indoor sport: trying to change each other. His answer has two sides. Don't judge each other in the gray areas, and don't use your freedom in a way that makes someone else stumble.

Key Takeaways

  • Romans 14:1–15:13 is the longest single argument in the letter, which may say something about how universal the problem is.
  • Paul is talking about gray areas, not places where Scripture has clearly spoken. Adultery is always wrong.
  • "Weak and strong" might better be "weak and less weak." Maturity brings more freedom, not more restrictions.
  • Don't judge: other believers are God's servants, not yours, and God sees the heart.
  • Don't cause others to stumble: freedom exercised without love can become a weapon.
  • Help people grow without dragging them. Nobody should stay at Candyland forever.
  • The kingdom of God is not eating and drinking but righteousness, peace, and joy in the Holy Spirit.

Comic Books, Card Games, and Raised Eyebrows

I love this passage. When my kids were younger, we let them read comic books. We had a lot of fun with it, but I have to tell you, many Christians questioned our sanity and the sincerity of our faith. When they'd say our kids were going to grow up to be delinquents. I'd say, "You mean like my husband?" He's read comic books since he was five.

So how do you handle that? What do you do when someone else is doing something you find very questionable, or when people are questioning what you're doing? That's the question Romans 14 sets out to answer.

Romans Review

In chapters 1 through 8, Paul lays out the gospel: salvation comes through faith in Jesus, not by keeping the law. In chapters 9 through 11, he argues that God has not rejected Israel, which shows he will be faithful to all who trust him. Chapter 12 begins the practical section. In response to everything God has done, how should we live?

In chapter 12, Paul tells us to think soberly about ourselves and to be passionate and generous toward others. In chapter 13, he tells us to submit to authority, because all authority is ultimately there because of God, and to keep ourselves free from debt and free from darkness so we're free to serve God. Now in chapter 14, he turns to our favorite indoor sport: trying to change each other.

This section runs from Romans 14:1 all the way through 15:13. It's one continuous argument, and Paul gives it more space than anything else in the letter. That may say something about how universal the problem is.

The Issues in Rome

Paul opens in verse 1: "As for the one who is weak in faith, welcome him, but not to quarrel over opinions."

The specific disputes he names involve food and sacred days. Some believers felt free to eat anything. Others, especially Jewish Christians who had grown up keeping kosher, could not bring themselves to eat meat that hadn't been slaughtered the right way. For them, it wasn't a matter of preference but of whether God would be offended. Some Gentile believers had a parallel struggle. Having come out of idol worship, they associated meat from the marketplace with animals sacrificed on pagan altars. Eating it felt like going back to something dark.

The disagreements over days were similar. Jewish believers had a full calendar of feasts and fasts. Gentile believers came from their own religious observances. Now that both were Christians, what should they do with those days? Had Christ's coming changed everything?

The underlying question on both sides was the same: how do we please God? I see the same thing today, maybe because I'm around so many older teenagers and young adults. There's this gap of "you're not doing it the way I like." They wear blue jeans to church. They don't act quite right. How can God be pleased with that?

Weak and Strong

Before we look at Paul's argument, let's talk about what he means by weak and strong. I'd say "weak and less weak" is probably a better way to think about it.

Throughout this section, Paul claims that those with the most freedom are the farthest along in the faith. In verse 14 he says, "I know and am persuaded in the Lord Jesus that nothing is unclean in itself," and basically argues for the liberal position. That surprised me when I first read it. The image of spiritual maturity many of us carry is the monk or the ascetic, someone who has given up everything and lives under severe restrictions. Paul seems to argue the opposite. As we mature, there will be fewer restrictions and fewer boundaries.

Think about why Jesus was so free to go to parties with drunkards and harlots. On the surface, that doesn't look like a good thing to do. But because he was spiritually perfect and mature, he knew he was going to change them. They weren't going to change him. He could walk into any situation and influence it without fear of it influencing him. Baby Christians don't have that freedom yet.

If you saw Mother Teresa entering a crack house, what would you assume? I'd assume she was there to minister to people who are lost and hurting and throwing their lives away, and that she'd come out okay. But if I saw my neighbor who'd had a 20-year crack habit and was a week old in the Lord go in, I would panic. I'd think he was going into a situation he couldn't handle. When we are immature in the faith, there are things we can't handle, and we have more boundaries. As we mature, there are more things we can do.

Now, don't take that too far. Some areas of Scripture are not debatable, and that's not what Paul is talking about. Promiscuity, adultery, things like that are always wrong. It doesn't matter how strong you are in the faith, you can't run a Christian brothel. It's just not allowed. Where God has spoken and said this is right and this is wrong, we are not free to change it. We're told to rebuke, encourage, and admonish each other in those areas, and even to discipline each other according to the patterns of Scripture. Where God has judged, we are free to say that is wrong. What Paul is addressing are the gray areas: music styles, holiday observances, entertainment, spending, the places where thoughtful, sincere believers land in different places.

Reason 1: It Is Not Your Job

So why are the weak and the strong not to look down on each other? Paul's first answer is that it's not our responsibility to change them. Look at verse 4:

Who are you to pass judgment on the servant of another? It is before his own master that he stands or falls. And he will be upheld, for the Lord is able to make him stand.

Your brother or sister in Christ is not your servant. They are God's servant. The responsibility to change them and mature them belongs to him, not to you.

It's a lot like family. You don't get to choose your parents or your in-laws or your siblings or your cousins. You accept them, not with the idea of straightening them out, but because they're family. It's your mother's uncle Herbert, and you just put up with him. And have you ever noticed who we complain about most in our families? It's usually our husbands. And he's the only one we got to pick.

Paul's point is that you don't get to choose who's in God's family either. God chooses, and it's our job to learn to love them.

Reason 2: God Sees the Heart

The second reason runs through verses 5 and 6. God sees what we cannot. If someone observes a certain day or avoids a certain food out of a sincere desire to honor God, then God receives that. We may think they're wrong. There may even be a right answer. But if the motivation is genuine devotion, God accepts it, and we're not in a position to overrule him.

That applies across a wide range of disagreements: how to celebrate Christmas, what kind of music belongs in worship, how to educate our children, what discipline should look like in a home. In all of those areas, I think we have to give the other person the benefit of the doubt that they're genuinely trying to honor God, even when we think they've gotten it wrong.

Reason 3: We Belong to God

In verses 7 through 12, Paul widens the picture. Whether a believer lives with great freedom or with significant restrictions, what matters is that they are living to the Lord. The goal is not conformity to any one person's standard. The goal is belonging to God and striving to follow him. And each of us will give an account of ourselves before God, not before each other.

I'm not sure I have this section fully figured out. But the core point seems clear. We are brothers and sisters, not each other's supervisors. God has the right to change people in his timing, at his pace, in his way. It's not up to any of us to force it.

So if you want to judge, judge yourself. Ask yourself: how are my attitudes and actions affecting other people? Am I criticizing someone in a way that hurts them? Am I questioning the sincerity of their faith, when that's really up to God?

The Other Side: Don't Cause Others to Stumble

Paul isn't finished at verse 12. Having told the stronger not to look down on the weaker, he turns to how the stronger use their freedom.

Therefore let us not pass judgment on one another any longer, but rather decide never to put a stumbling block or hindrance in the way of a brother. -- Romans 14:13

Freedom is real. Paul is persuaded that nothing is unclean in itself. But as we mature, we may go into situations that would have tempted us before, or celebrate in ways we didn't before, and Paul's language is: make sure you're not causing others to stumble. Others are watching, and what you do has an influence. "If your brother is grieved by what you eat, you are no longer walking in love."

"Do not put a stumbling block in front of someone" is pretty strong language. I was trying to figure out how to explain it. Have you been watching the Olympics? I happened to be watching the women's snowboarders. There were about five women going down the hill, and they came over a bump, and one crossed in front of another just ever so slightly. Their snowboards nicked, and they just went flying. I thought, they've probably been training for decades for this minute and thirty seconds of glory, and now they've hit each other and wiped out. It's all over in one horrible crash.

That's the image. God has people on a path, running the race he has set before them, and you don't want to get in their way and cause them to wipe out like that.

In our family, our kids could read comic books at home, but they couldn't take them to school or church. If it caused others to worry or stumble, that was out of bounds. If you enjoy wine with dinner and a friend struggles with drinking, put the wine away. And in my own teaching, I believe Scripture allows women to teach men in certain contexts, but there are places I won't do it, because the controversy would overwhelm the message. The gospel matters more than exercising my right.

A Rope Bridge and a Board Game

Ray Stedman, one of my early pastors, used to liken this to crossing one of those rickety rope bridges you see in the movies, over some huge canyon with boards missing. Some people just run across without even holding the railings. Others step out an inch at a time, or get down on all fours and crawl their way across. That's how we are in the Christian life. Some of us move faster and some slower, and it would be cruel to grab someone who is crawling and drag them across before they're ready.

There will always be someone stronger than you in some area of faith, and someone weaker. If your racing across is causing someone else to stumble, slow down and walk with them for a while.

But Paul isn't saying to leave people stuck. There may be times you want to challenge someone to think, but you do it lovingly, not from "How can you be a Christian and say that?" but from "Let's see what Scripture says. Let's see where we can go from here."

The analogy I like for this is board games. My husband loves games, and he was delighted when we had kids, because it gave him a chance to play all kinds of games and call it good fatherhood. And it was. Some of you may be in this stage now: when our kids were little, we must have played Candyland until we were ready to scream. It's completely boring and endlessly repetitive, and there's no strategy. And yet our kids loved it, and it was really all they could do. They were learning their colors and learning to count. But you don't want to stay at Candyland. You want to move on to Monopoly or Scrabble or Risk, something that takes more skill.

Paul isn't advocating that we stay stuck in the Candyland stage. He wants growth and maturity. So don't cause someone to stumble, but don't leave them in their weakness either. Love them. Seek to serve them. Look at how your actions are affecting them. If challenging them causes them to question and think and go back to Scripture, keep at it. If it causes them to stumble and grieve and fall into confusion, stop and back off.

What Actually Matters

For the kingdom of God is not a matter of eating and drinking but of righteousness and peace and joy in the Holy Spirit. Whoever thus serves Christ is acceptable to God and approved by men. -- Romans 14:17–18

The kingdom of God is not about the gray areas that divide believers, whatever form those take in a given culture or decade. It's about righteousness, peace, and joy in the Holy Spirit. If giving up something you are perfectly free to do brings about peace and unity and furthers righteousness, nothing of eternal value has been lost.

The list of things Christians have argued about over the centuries is endless and ever-changing: comic books, electric guitars, zippers versus buttons, cable television, pink hair. What's on the list matters less than the posture we bring to the disagreement. Judge yourself. Love your family. Leave the changing to God.

Next: 22 How to Disagree Without Dividing (Romans 14:19-15:13)

Previous: 20 Why Owing Nothing but Love Sets You Free From Darkness (Romans 13:8–14)

Series: Romans: Justification by Faith

Study: Romans Resources

AI-generated image created by the author.

Season 2, Episode 21

Page Views: 1,227