05 Why It Matters that Abraham was Saved by Faith (Romans 4)

by Krisan Marotta | Jun 11, 2013 | 01 Podcasts, Romans

Updated November 2026

The rabbis of Paul's day were sure Abraham was justified by keeping the law, and they had a verse to prove it. In Romans 4, Paul turns that example completely around. Abraham and David show us two sinners who trusted God, and the faith that was counted to Abraham as righteousness is offered to us.

Key Takeaways

  • Abraham matters to Judaism, Islam, and Mormonism, so it matters enormously what his example actually is.
  • If Abraham were justified by works, righteousness would be a wage God owes. Paul says it is a gift to the one who trusts "Him who justifies the ungodly."
  • David, a murderer and adulterer, calls himself blessed because God covered his sins.
  • Abraham was declared righteous about fourteen years before he was circumcised. The sign added nothing to his standing.
  • A promise that depends on our keeping the law is no promise at all. A promise that rests on grace is guaranteed.
  • Even faith is part of the gift. If yours is weak, ask him.

Review

Romans 4 wraps up the first section of the letter. Chapters 1-4 have covered a single major point: no one is righteous. We have all sinned and fallen short of the glory of God. It is not the hearers of the law who are justified, but the doers of the law, and no one can keep the law.

That is not a radical idea for Christians today. But to Paul's Jewish audience, it would have been far more provocative, which is why he spent so much time proving it.

Starting in chapter 5, Paul turns to answer the question: so what? If everything I have been saying is true, what difference does it make in your life today? Chapters 5 through 8 are where he works that out, and some people have called that section the highlight of Romans. Some have even called it the highlight of the New Testament itself.

But first, chapter 4. Paul turns to Abraham.

Why Abraham Matters

Three other major religions outside of Christianity are rooted in Abraham: Judaism, Islam, and Mormonism.

Judaism's connection is obvious, sharing the same lineage as Christianity. Islam holds that the line of promise ran through Ishmael, not Isaac, and that anyone who rejects the prophet Abraham is not a true believer. Asking God to send His blessings upon Abraham is part of one of the five daily prayers. Muhammad is considered a descendant of Abraham through Ishmael.

Mormonism places a high emphasis on the priesthood of Melchizedek, which points to Abraham's importance. Beyond that, their canon includes a text called the Book of Abraham, which Joseph Smith claimed to have translated from an Egyptian manuscript written in Abraham's own hand. Copies of what he translated still exist, and scholars have concluded it was a funeral dirge with no connection to Abraham.

Given Abraham's reach across these traditions, and given that Paul is about to argue that everyone must follow Abraham's example to be saved, it matters enormously what that example actually is. Other religions would agree that you must follow Abraham's example, but would differ on what following him means.

How Abraham Was Justified

Paul sets up his argument in chapter 3 with three claims. 1) The gospel ends our pride. 2) The gospel ends our prejudice. 3) The gospel fulfills the law. Chapter 4 illustrates all three through the life of Abraham.

The Jewish teachers of Paul's day believed Abraham was justified by keeping the law. Their case rested on a passage in Genesis 26:5, where God tells Isaac that Abraham obeyed his voice and kept his charge, his commandments, his statutes, and his laws. The rabbis read that and concluded the proof was right there in God's own words. One rabbi wrote that Abraham had performed the whole law before it was given and was one of the righteous ones not needing repentance.

So Paul faces a direct challenge. He has spent three chapters arguing no one is justified by keeping the law. The rabbis say Abraham was, and they have a verse to prove it. Paul has to deal with that.

His answer is to argue the exact opposite: Abraham's life does not show a man who kept the law and was justified by it. It shows a man who had faith and was justified by it.

Wages Versus Gifts

Paul lays out the logic in verses 2 through 5. If Abraham was justified by works, then God owes him something. If you work for a wage, your employer is not giving you a gift. He is paying what he owes you. So if God owes Abraham righteousness, it is a wage, not a gift.

On the other hand, if justification comes through faith apart from the law, then God owes us nothing. Righteousness is something he freely gives.

It is worth noting how Paul describes God in this passage. He calls Him "Him who justifies the ungodly." That phrasing is a signal of where Paul is heading. Abraham knew he was ungodly, and he trusted the One who justifies the ungodly.

So if you look at Abraham's life, what do you see? A perfect life, or examples of sin? During the first half of his life, he was an idol worshipper living in Ur. When God brought him out and there was famine in the land, he fled to Egypt and almost caused his wife to commit adultery with Pharaoh. He repeats the sin a few years later. Remember those verses in Deuteronomy from chapter 3: how much of the law do you have to keep? All of it. How much do you have to break to fail? Any of it. There are times we see Abraham make mistakes and fail. But what do we see in this passage? We see Abraham trusting God.

The passage Paul quotes is Genesis 15:1–6. God calls Abraham outside, tells him to count the stars, and says his offspring will be just as numerous. Abraham had no child. Sarah had never conceived. They were both old. And yet he believed the Lord, and it was counted to him as righteousness.

The rabbis tried to fold this in by arguing that Abraham's faith was itself such a great act that it became his work, the wage that required God to grant him righteousness. Paul will go on to argue that even faith is part of the gift. Faith is not something we muster up to get God to bless us. It is not our contribution to the arrangement. It is part of what God gives.

If faith were something we achieved, we could boast in it. We could point to how much we had and say we earned what we received. That is not the picture Paul is painting, and it is not the picture Abraham's life presents.

David as a Second Witness

Paul brings in David as a second argument. In verses 6 through 8, he quotes Psalm 32: "Blessed are those whose lawless deeds are forgiven and whose sins are covered. Blessed is the man against whom the Lord will not count his sin."

David wrote Psalm 32 after the story recorded in 2 Samuel 11. Rather than go out to battle with his men, he stayed home. He saw a woman bathing from his rooftop and used his office as king to pursue her. He misused that office a second time to try to get her husband Uriah to come home from the battlefield so the resulting pregnancy would appear to be his. When that failed, he arranged for Uriah to be placed at the front lines where he was killed in the fighting. Then he married Bathsheba.

He thought he had covered it all until Nathan confronted him.

After that, David writes that he is blessed. A murderer and an adulterer who has abused every privilege God gave him says he is fortunate, lucky, blessed. Why? Because God covers his sins. There is no reference in the Psalm to any need for sacrifice or ritual offerings. David simply says he cried out to God and God forgave him.

Paul's point is consider Abraham and David. Do you see two men who earned their salvation, or do you see two sinners who trusted God to cover their sins?

The Gospel Ends Prejudice

In verses 9 through 12, Paul shifts from pride to prejudice. If no one is righteous and everyone stands under the same judgment, then no one has grounds to look down on anyone else.

The Jewish boast in Paul's day was that they had exclusive access to God. They were the heirs of the blessing of Abraham. They understood that the promise included the nations, but they believed Gentiles had to become Jews to receive it, which meant circumcision. Jewish believers were telling Gentile converts they had to be circumcised as part of their conversion.

Paul's question is simple: when was Abraham declared righteous? Before or after circumcision?

The answer is before, by roughly fourteen years. Circumcision was a sign and seal of a standing before God that Abraham already had. It did not create anything new. It did not enhance his position. It was an outward symbol of a reality that had already taken place.

The analogy I like to use here is my wedding ring. When I made vows to my husband, we exchanged rings, but the ring itself does not make me married. If our rings hadn't come for six months or a year after the wedding, we would still have been married. It's merely an outward symbol of the vows we took. If I lose my ring, it doesn't mean I'm not married and now free to do whatever I want. And if I wear the ring and completely disregard my vows, I'm not gaining anything by wearing it.

Circumcision worked the same way for Abraham. It added nothing to his standing before God.

So Abraham was like the Gentile believers in that he was justified before circumcision, and like the Jewish believers in that he later received the sign. God arranged it that way on purpose, Paul says, to make the point that Abraham is the father of all who believe, regardless of which side of circumcision they stand on. What makes someone a son of Abraham is sharing his faith, not sharing his ancestry.

Jesus makes the same argument in John 8. The Pharisees claim they are sons of Abraham, and Jesus replies that they may be physical descendants, but they are not living like him. They do not have his faith. Physical lineage is not the point.

The Gospel Fulfills the Law

In verses 13 through 17, Paul turns to his third claim: the gospel fulfills the law.

The logic goes like this. Imagine someone offers you a gift, free and clear. All you have to do is ask. But then they add a condition. And another. And another. At some point you stop calling it a gift. It has become a set of requirements you may never be able to meet.

That is what Paul is arguing against. If God's promise to Abraham was based on the law, it was no promise at all. It was null and void from the start. A promise is something the one who makes it is responsible to keep. The moment you add requirements that the recipient must fulfill, you shift the responsibility onto their shoulders. And once it is on our shoulders, it is no longer guaranteed, because we can fail.

Verse 16 makes it plain: it depends on faith so that the promise may rest on grace and be guaranteed. It is guaranteed because God is the one doing it. He said he would. We can trust him. Our failures do not cause him to withdraw a promise he has already given.

There is a brief phrase in this section about the law bringing wrath and there being no transgression without the law. The point is that without the law, we can rationalize anything. We can tell ourselves our particular lie was justified, our particular failure was understandable. The law removes that excuse. It draws the line and shows us we have crossed it. In that sense the gospel fulfills the law, because the law's purpose was always to show us that on our own, we cannot get there.

Abraham's Faith

The chapter closes with a portrait of what Abraham's faith actually looked like.

He believed in hope against hope. When he looked at the evidence, there was no reason to expect a child. He was around a hundred years old. Sarah had never conceived. Humanly speaking, it was impossible. But God had spoken, and Abraham trusted the God who gives life to the dead and calls into existence things that do not exist.

His faith began with a specific, revealed person. It was not a vague spirituality or a sincere commitment to whatever felt true. Abraham believed in a God who had spoken to him, made specific claims, and made specific promises. There's a Peanuts cartoon in which Linus says, "It doesn't matter what you believe as long as you're sincere." That was pretty funny when it was written, but a lot of people today take it seriously. It is not what we see in Abraham. He trusted someone specific.

His faith was also grounded not in his own ideas but in what God had revealed. He did not dream up a plan and pitch it to God. He held on to what God had promised. The more we know what God has actually said, the more grounded our faith becomes and the less we are carried off by every new movement or philosophy that arrives.

And he did not waver. He considered his own body, saw clearly that it was as good as dead, and kept trusting anyway. That is likely why, when God later asked him to sacrifice Isaac, he was willing. He trusted in a God who can bring life from the dead. He probably did not understand what God was doing, but he knew God would do what he said.

The Same Faith Is Available to Us

Paul's conclusion is that Abraham's faith is not some unique historical achievement. It is offered to us.

The words written about Abraham were not written for his sake alone, but for ours. It will be counted to us who believe in him who raised Jesus from the dead, who was delivered up for our trespasses and raised for our justification.

Our faith, like Abraham's, is in hope and against hope. Abraham believed in a God who would bring life from the dead. We believe in one who already has. We have seen the body of Jesus broken, beaten, and buried, and raised again. Abraham believed the promise. We have seen it fulfilled.

We look at our lives and think: how do you stop being selfish? How do you rebuild a marriage that is crumbling, or repair a relationship with a child that has been torn apart, or find your footing in a hostile workplace or a secular university? Humanly speaking, it is impossible. But we have seen the impossible happen. We have seen a hundred-year-old man become a father. We have seen a dead man walk out of a tomb.

The faith that counted for Abraham counts for us. It is not something to work up and present to God as proof of our sincerity. It is part of the gift. If you feel your faith is weak, if you are stumbling, ask him. He will answer it. It may involve suffering. It usually does. But he will answer it.

As Charles Wesley wrote:

In hope against all human hope, self-desperate, I believe.

Faith, mighty faith, the promise sees, and looks to that alone,

laughs at the impossibilities, and cries, it shall be done.

That is the example of Abraham: to have the faith that he had. In chapter 5, one of my favorite chapters in the book, Paul turns to answer the question: if all of this is true, so what?

Next: 06 You Will Be Good Enough: Three Reasons to Rejoice (Romans 5:1-11)

Previous: 04 Why Self-Help Fails and What Frees You (Romans 3)

Series: Romans: Justification by Faith

Study: Romans Resources

AI-generated image created by the author.

Season 2, Episode 5

Page Views: 1,055