08 Why Grace Is Not a License to Sin (Romans 6:1-14)

by Krisan Marotta | Jul 2, 2013 | 01 Podcasts, Romans

Updated November 2026

If God's grace abounds over our sin, shouldn't we keep sinning so grace can increase? In Romans 6:1-14, Paul answers his critics with an emphatic no. Grace doesn't just pay the penalty for sin. It turns us back to God and breaks sin's mastery over us. We may still lose battles, but the war has already been won.

Key Takeaways

  • In Romans 6-8, Paul answers the objections his detractors would raise against the gospel.
  • Grace does more than satisfy God's wrath. It solves the problem of sin itself and turns us back to God.
  • "Dying to sin" uses the language of slavery: no one could own a dead slave. Sin is no longer our master.
  • The change from old self to new self is a change in our relationship to God, not in our abilities.
  • The cross guarantees three things: the penalty is paid, sin's dominion is broken, and our full salvation is certain.
  • Knowing you will win doesn't make you passive. It frees you to pursue holiness with joy and purpose.

Romans Review

In Romans 1-5, Paul argues that everyone is sinful and no one can keep the law. The law requires that we keep it with our whole heart, all the time, all of it. There is no way we can be justified because we fail. We simply cannot do it.

Paul announces that there is a way to be justified, and that is through faith in Jesus Christ. Then in chapters 3 and 4, he argues that everyone who has ever been justified has been justified through faith. He uses Abraham and David as examples.

In Romans 5, he answers the question: so what? His answer is that we rejoice in the hope of the glory of God. We exult and boast because we know that we will in fact be saved from our sinfulness and be made holy.

Then in the second part of chapter 5, he argues another way and says that grace prevails over wrath. It is not that God had two 50-50 options — wrath or mercy — and flipped a coin. His mercy and grace were the prevailing, overwhelming, abounding force, and they triumph over his judgment.

A Question-and-Answer Section

Now in chapter 6, Paul moves into a question-and-answer format. He does this from chapters 6 through 8. Then in chapters 9 through 11, he talks about the role of the Jews in all of this. It is not until chapter 12 that he gives the practical implications for how to live.

The questions he is dealing with are not questions of clarification from a sincere and eager disciple. They are the questions his detractors would pose.

The first question is this: shall we sin that grace might increase?

If what you are saying is true, Paul, means we ought to keep sinning. Because the more we sin, the more God has to forgive. The more God forgives, the more he is glorified. And we want to glorify God, so shouldn't we just go out and keep sinning?

You might ask why Paul would answer questions like this if Romans is written to believers. The Roman believers would not pose them, would they? But remember, he is still in a didactic section of the book. He is building a case and an argument. As these people learn and share the gospel he is preparing them for questions that will be raised.

This is still very useful today. These same questions come up.

The Core Argument: What Grace Actually Does

To explain the problem, picture two hands facing each other — that is us and God, face to face in fellowship before the fall. What happens at the fall is we turn our backs on God and say, I don't need you anymore. I am going to be God. I am going to decide what is right and wrong. And God, in response, turns his back on us. He essentially says: you want sin, you've got it. This is God's wrath: turning his back on us and saying, now you are trapped, now you are in the custody of sin and death.

What happens at the cross is that Jesus' death solves the problem of God's wrath. It pays the penalty for our sins such that God can turn back to us.

The force behind the objection is real. The fact that God solved our problem while our backs were turned is an amazing act of grace. This is an overwhelming act of love. So why shouldn't we stay in that position? It shows this wonderful aspect of God's character. We should just keep sinning because it showcases his grace.

Yes, grace solves the problem of God's wrath. But grace does one more thing. It solves the problem of our sinfulness itself, and it makes it possible for God to turn us back to him.

Part of the gift is forgiveness. Part of the gift is solving the problem of sin itself.

So his answer is this: if part of the gift is to turn us back to God, why would we keep our backs turned? Why would we live as if that is not true? We would make a mockery of the gift, because part of the gift is to draw us back to him. That is really the passage in a nutshell. The spirit of the question is: why shouldn't we keep our backs turned? And Paul's answer is: because part of the gift is to turn us back to him, and you don't want to ignore that.

Dying to Sin

Before we go verse by verse, one important point about context. Paul is not trying to give us a how-to for walking day to day in our lives. He is not going to start that until chapter 12. People misunderstand this passage when they take it out of context and ask: what does this mean about the next five minutes and my sinfulness? To try to make this passage teach us how to deal with sin moment by moment is to miss his point, and that is where we can go astray.

Now look at his answer in verse 2. "By no means. How can we who died to sin still live in it?"

That phrase "by no means" is a wonderful Greek expression. It means: absolutely not, never, not even close. Emphatically no. It is very strong.

"How can we who died to sin still live in it" is really the summary of where he is going. We often miss this. When we come to faith in Jesus, we learn that his death paid the penalty for our sins. The cross satisfies justice. That is true.

But for many of us, our understanding stops there. It is true that the cross guarantees our salvation in the sense that the penalty has been paid. But there is more to it. It also guarantees that we will be saved from sin itself, from the power of sin in our lives.

It is not as if God said: okay, you are out of jail, now go back to a life of crime. What kind of salvation is that? The life of crime is what we want to be saved from.

His argument is: it is not just that you have been gotten out of jail. It is that now you have a life that was not possible before. You have a hope of the glory of God that you never had before.

Let me be clear on that. Nowhere does the Bible promise that this transformation from ungodliness to godliness will happen instantaneously. It never promises that. On the contrary, it promises that this is going to be a long, gradual, step-by-step process. There is one point where Paul talks about being changed in the twinkling of an eye, but that is in the context of the last trumpet sounding. This side of heaven, the transformation is not instantaneous. Scripture never promises that you are suddenly and completely holy.

So when we look at our lives and see all these flavors of selfishness, it is tempting to ask: how can Paul claim we have died to sin? All I have to do is look at yesterday to see that I am sinful, my family is sinful, we are still there. How can he say this?

The promise is not that we will have victory over every battle with every sin. The promise is that we will win the war. The victor in the battle has been declared. Sin is going to lose and we are going to win, and that is an absolute guaranteed fact.

In the next five minutes, sin may defeat me. But that does not negate the truth that the power of sin has been broken in my life by the cross. It just means the power of that breaking has not yet been fully realized. It will happen, it is coming, but it is not fully realized yet.

Slavery and Freedom

What does Paul mean when he talks about dying to sin? The metaphor he is continuing is the one he began in chapter 1, where he talks about being handed over to sin and death, handed into their custody. Sin was our master and we were its slaves. We were legally bound to sin.

The reason he uses the language of dying to sin is that this is how a slave became free. No one could own a dead slave. Once a slave died, their master had no claim over them. So the metaphor is: we have died to our sinful master, and we have been raised to a new master, which is God. As long as we were alive in the old sense, sin was our master. But through belief in Jesus, we have metaphorically died, and now sin is no longer our master.

How could you live as if sin was still your master when it no longer is?

Verse 3: "Do you not know that all of us who have been baptized into Christ Jesus were baptized into his death?"

Being baptized into Jesus' death is the idea that just as Jesus literally physically died, so we have metaphorically died, and when we died, sin ceased to be our master. The only way you could think you would want to continue to pursue sin is if you did not know that part of grace was to remove us from that.

Again, he is not addressing the momentary everyday struggle. He is looking at what is the tenor and direction of my life. When all is said and done, where am I headed? Whose child am I? What controls me? What is my hope?

He is not trying to give some key to how to win the next skirmish in the war. He is making the point that the war has been won and the victor has been declared.

Buried and Raised

Verses 4 through 7 from the English Standard Version: "We were buried, therefore, with him by baptism into death, in order that just as Christ was raised from the dead by the glory of the Father, we too might walk in newness of life. For if we have been united with him in a death like his, we shall certainly be united with him in a resurrection like his. We know that our old self was crucified with him, in order that the body of sin might be brought to nothing, so that we would no longer be enslaved to sin. For the one who has died has been set free from sin."

To paraphrase, he is saying: just as Jesus physically died and was physically raised from the dead, so we metaphorically died to our old master — which was sin — and we have been metaphorically raised to a new master, which is God. He is emphasizing now not just the death but the resurrection. The relationship has been restored. We have been turned back to God. It is not just that the penalty was paid. We have this newness of life. Sin used to be our master. Now it is God.

Remember the point he is trying to argue. The context is: if your gospel is true, Paul, shouldn't we continue to sin? He is not answering the question of whether a believer will continue to sin. He is answering a theological point: should I continue? Isn't this a logical implication of your gospel? And he is saying no, because we have been raised to this newness of life. We have a life that is ultimately not controlled by sin.

Verse 5 re-emphasizes the point. Why would God forgive us our sins but leave us trapped in them? If we have been united in his death, we shall certainly be united in his resurrection. Why would he free us from the penalty and leave us trapped in sin? Just as Jesus was raised to newness of life, don't you think God is going to raise us to newness of life and give us hope where we had no hope?

Old Self, New Self: What Changed

The old self and new self is often a confusing metaphor. By old self, Paul means nothing more than the me who was trapped in sin, the me who had no hope. The change between old self and new self is not a change in abilities. The change is in my relationship to God, and that is key.

The old me was trapped in sin because God had his back turned to me. The new me is no longer trapped because God's back is no longer turned. I am still the same person. Same weaknesses, same likes, same dislikes, same scars, same background, same experiences. But now I have hope, and I had no hope before.

There is a sense in which nothing about me has changed, and there is a sense in which everything about me has changed.

Think of it this way. We are back in the Civil War era, and a Union soldier rides in and says: the war is over, the Emancipation Proclamation has been signed, there is no more slavery. And I am standing there a slave, and I might throw my hat in the air and say, I am a new man. Well, nothing about me has changed. Same gray hair, same scars, same limp, same problems. On the other hand, I have hope I never had before. I have a possibility I never had before. In a very real sense, everything has changed because now the direction and the ultimate goal of my life can be radically altered.

That is Paul's metaphor for the old man and the new man. What has changed is my relationship to God.

He is not claiming that our new self will no longer struggle with sin. The promise of new life is not a guarantee that you will never sin again. The promise of new life is a guarantee that you have hope.

When I was trapped in sin and faced moral struggles under the law, I had no way out. I could just keep trying, try harder, try harder. I was still going to fail, nothing was going to change. Once Jesus comes into my life and solves not only the forgiveness problem but also the fact of my sinfulness, now I have hope. When I face those battles, it does not guarantee I am going to win every one. But it guarantees that I am moving in the direction of righteousness, and God is going to use all of that to make me the person he wants me to be.

Why Such Absolute Language?

You might ask why Paul uses such absolute language throughout this section. He talks about the old man, the new man, one destroyed, one dead, one crucified. It was this way, now it is that way. Very black and white.

That trips a lot of people up, because all you have to do is live one day and you can see that we still sin. Every Christian for 2,000 years has struggled with sin.

One commentator used the analogy that the old man is like a dead dog. The dog is dead, but he is not gone. You still drag him around on the leash, but he is dead because the problem has been solved. When you kick him, he doesn't bark.

The problem is that my dead dog does bark. And he bites too. If you give him half a chance, he is going to bark and bite just fine.

The deeper problem with that analogy is: who is going to break the leash? Now you have added something. Jesus' death killed the dog, but someone has to come along and cut the leash. Who is that going to be? It cannot be me. I know I cannot do it.

Most people who follow that kind of theology would say you can, and they give you the keys to victorious Christian living and the steps you need to take to cut the leash. But think back to Romans 5. If it is up to me to cut the leash, how can Paul argue that our hope will not disappoint because God loves us? Paul seems to think it is up to God for that leash to be cut.

If I have to learn on my own to break this problem of sin, then it is on my shoulders and not on God's. And now I have a problem, because I do not know that I can do it. I am still struggling. I would sell my birthright for a pot of porridge given half a chance. If I am honest, that is who I am.

But all through chapter 5, Paul argued that your hope is absolutely guaranteed because God loves you enough to get you there. If he loved you enough to die for you while you were his enemy, then he certainly loves you enough to get you to your inheritance.

The Body of Sin

There is one more phrase worth noting: "in order that this body of sin might be brought to nothing." The word "body" here was a slang term for a slave in the Greek world, similar to a derogatory term used in the antebellum South. Paul is using that slang to say: this slavery, this me who is a slave to sin, would be brought to nothing. Some people think he is using the literal physical body. Either way, you arrive at the same place. The me who was controlled by sin no longer exists because what has changed is my relationship to God and the fact that I now have hope.

Verses 8 through 10: "Now if we have died with Christ, we believe that we will also live with him. We know that Christ being raised from the dead will never die again. Death no longer has dominion over him. For the death he died, he died to sin once for all, and the life he lives, he lives to God."

He is making the same point again. Just as Christ's physical death was followed by a physical resurrection, our metaphorical death to sin is followed by a metaphorical resurrection, so that we now have life under God. Eventually there will come a physical resurrection for us as well, but that is not what he has in mind here. His point is that death is no longer master. Just as death no longer had dominion over Christ, so sin no longer has dominion over us in the sense that we will not ultimately lose. The war has been won. God has declared that we are going to win in the long run.

The resurrection proved literally and physically that death was no longer Jesus' master. The picture for us is that sin is no longer our master. Part of the gift of grace is freeing us from the custody and tyranny of sin. We have hope — not that we are perfect, not that we are completely holy, but that we have this new destiny. We have possibilities we never had before. We have access to the Spirit of God we did not have before. We have a hope of being freed.

What the Gospel Implies

Verses 11 through 14 sum this all up. It is an exhortation, and I think his point is to say: if you want to know the implication of my gospel, here it is.

"So you also must consider yourselves dead to sin but alive to God in Jesus Christ. Let not sin therefore reign in your mortal body to make you obey its passions. Do not present your members to sin as instruments for unrighteousness, but present yourselves to God as those who have been brought from death to life, and your members to God as instruments for righteousness. For sin will have no dominion over you, since you are not under law but under grace."

The dominion aspect is being emphasized. His conclusion is: if you want to understand the implications of my gospel, it is this: part of the gift of grace was to set you free from the problem of sin, not just the penalty of it but the fact of it in your life. Because we have been justified by the cross, sin is no longer our master. So don't live like it is.

The logical conclusion of his gospel is not: pursue sin. It is: strive after holiness. He brings it all back to justification. You are not under law, but under grace.

Three Things the Cross Guarantees

Let me summarize what we have learned in chapters 5 and 6 together, because I think there is one more aspect of the cross we sometimes miss.

The first aspect of the cross is that Jesus' death pays the penalty for our sins.

The second is what we have been looking at in chapter 6. It deals with the problem of sin itself. It will no longer have dominion over us. God did not give us a get-out-of-jail-free card to throw us back into a life of crime. He got us out of jail so that he could make us righteous, good, and holy people. That is a long process, not an instantaneous one.

The third implication is probably the most significant of all. Jesus' death on the cross guarantees our full salvation. We cannot miss it, cannot fall short of it, cannot hinder it, cannot stop it, cannot get in the way. By full salvation I do not mean just our justification, just the penalty being paid. I mean the full fact of sin in our lives. We have absolute confidence that one day all the effects of sin and ungodliness will be removed. All the wrongs will be put right. All the tears will be wiped away. All the hurts, the wrongs, the frustration, the bitterness — all of it will be put right one day. And we will be transformed from wicked, ungodly people to godly, righteous people. The cross guarantees it. We cannot miss it.

We tend to accept pretty easily that Jesus' death paid the penalty for our sins. He went to the cross claiming he was going to do that, he took our place, he died, the sacrifice was once for all, no more death is necessary. When God raised Jesus from the dead, he declared that he had accepted that sacrifice. It was good. So we have that guarantee, and we do not argue with it.

But the guarantee of our eventual glorification still gives us trouble. Moment by moment, day by day, we face moral choices. Sometimes we choose right and sometimes we do not. We tend to think that if we are choosing right more often than not, we are making progress. And if we are choosing wrong more often than not, then we are stuck, and there must be something we need to do to get unstuck.

Therein lies the problem. There is nothing you can do to get unstuck. It is all in God's hands, and he will get you there.

Some people say: I know the cross guarantees the possibility for me to become a godly person. It breaks the mastery of sin and makes me free to choose righteousness if I really want it. But it only makes righteousness possible. It doesn't guarantee that I'm going to want it enough.

A lot of people think that way. Some denominations teach it. But from what we have learned in chapters 5 and 6, I do not think it is true. Because in chapter 5, Paul argues that you will not be disappointed in your hope because God loves you. He is assuming it is on God's shoulders. Then he makes the further point that grace abounds over wrath. If God loved you enough to save you while you were under wrath, and if grace is this overwhelming, abounding force, then don't you think he loves you enough to get you the rest of the way?

That is great news.

I know that deep down inside me there is something that wants righteousness, that longs for it and hates the fact that I am sinful. But at the same time, deep down, at any given moment I could give it all up in some fit of unbridled passion and toss all of this out the window. I am capable of it. I would be kidding myself to deny it. I am not faithful, I am fickle. I am not wise, I am foolish. It would not be surprising at all for me to reject all of this for some momentary pleasure.

Look at the heroes of the faith. Peter denied his Lord. David committed murder and adultery. Solomon committed great sexual sins. These were people who had a closeness to God that most of us only dream about, and they failed. So how do we know we will not do the same?

What Paul is telling us is that the cross guarantees that you will not ultimately lose. No matter how hard it gets, no matter how terrible the temptations or the struggles, you will get there. Why? Because God loves you. Because grace abounds over sin. Because part of the gift is not just paying the penalty but restoring the relationship and giving you hope where you had no hope.

Responding with Gratitude and Purpose

The question is how we respond. First, obviously, we ought to be profoundly and utterly grateful. God did not have to save us. He owed us nothing, and yet he did everything to make our salvation possible.

But the other question is: should we continue to sin because we are forgiven? No. Because you know the very thing your heart desires, you are going to get. Suppose your heart's desire is to win a gold medal in the Olympics, and someone said to you: I have a crystal ball, I have seen the future, you are going to win the gold. Would you then say, great, I will sit on the couch and watch TV? No. If you really want to win that gold medal, you will try all the harder. You can practice with joy and with purpose, knowing that your efforts are not in vain, that you are going to make progress and get there.

The point is you can go out and fully engage in life and all its ups and downs, knowing you are going to win. Yes, it is going to hurt at times. Yes, you are going to face struggles. Yes, sin will defeat you. But it will not ultimately win.

If you are trapped in a bad marriage, or you have a broken relationship with a child, or you face chronic health problems, or terminal financial woes, or a boss from hell, how do you get through? Paul says you get through because you know you have hope. No matter what happens, God is in control. No matter what the next five minutes bring or the next five years bring, God has promised to use that to bring you one step closer to the very thing your heart desires. He is going to get you to godliness no matter what. And you can face all of that with certainly some fear and trepidation, yes it hurts, yes you are tempted to despair — but even then you do not face it as one who has no hope. You have hope.

I think that is what the Bible means when it talks about the peace of God that surpasses all understanding. This confidence that no matter what, God is going to get you there. You cannot lose it, cannot mess it up, cannot stop it, cannot break it, and you do not have to pray for some other miracle to come along and save you. God has already done everything necessary to get you there.

So when Paul says consider yourselves dead to sin but alive to God, he is saying: know that you have hope. Know that the war, even though it is not over yet, even though you are still fighting the battles, you are going to win.

Face it with confidence. Sometimes with fear and trepidation too but knowing that God is on your side. Do not pursue sin. Pursue righteousness, knowing that there is a God who is watching every step of the way and will get you to the end.

Sometimes he uses your struggles. Sometimes he uses your failures to bring you to the next step. If there is some sin in your life that you have prayed to be released from, and the answer has not come when you wanted it — that is not because he no longer loves you or has forgotten about you. It is because this is what is best. This is the tool he is using to make you a person of faith, to make you a person who loves him.

Look at Abraham. He received promises that he would become a great nation, and it was about four hundred years later that they began coming true, except for Isaac. God's timetable is not our timetable. We want answers in five minutes. We have instant email, instant internet, everything is fast, and we want results in five minutes. God just does not work that way. Sometimes the answer is wait, and wait again, and wait longer. But it does not mean he does not love you. It does not mean he has forgotten you. It means this is part of the plan.

Yes, it is hard. Yes, it involves struggling. Yes, it often involves pain. But you will win. That is guaranteed. Sin will not be master over you, for you are not under the law. You are under grace. And that is our hope.

Next: 09 If We Can't Lose Grace, Why Not Sin? (Romans 6:15-7:6)

Previous: 07 Why Grace Outweighs Sin (Romans 5:12-21)

Series: Romans: Justification by Faith

Study: Romans Resources

AI-generated image created by the author.

Season 2, Episode 8

Page Views: 1,752