Updated November 2026
Romans 7:15 was a turning point in my life: "I do not understand my own actions, for I do not do what I want, but I do the very thing I hate." In Romans 7:7–25, Paul shows that the law is not evil. It is a gift that diagnoses our sin. Then he describes the struggle every believer knows, having the desire to do right but not the ability. That struggle raises the hard question of free will and God's sovereignty, and I'll give you my best attempt at putting them together.
Key Takeaways
- The law is holy, righteous, and good. It doesn't make us sinful. It shows us that we are sinful so we will look for a Savior.
- Paul highlights the tenth commandment because coveting is an inward sin no amount of outward religion can hide.
- The law is our diagnosis. We were just as sick before it, but now we know.
- Romans 7 describes the believer's present struggle: the desire to do what is right without the ability to carry it out.
- Paul isn't saying "the devil made me do it." He accepts full responsibility: "Wretched man that I am."
- Free will is uncoerced but not undetermined. We choose freely according to our nature, and our nature is broken.
- God is not obligated to change our nature, but he does. Our obedience is the fruit of his work, not the root of it.
Romans Review
Chapter 1 tells us we all sinned, that we now experience death, and that God abandoned us to that sin and death.
Chapter 2 tells us no one is saved by keeping the law, not the moral person or the religious person. No one is exempt from the disease of sin.
In chapter 3, Paul finally announces the good news: we can be justified by trusting that God will forgive us because of Jesus' death on the cross.
In chapter 4, he argues that even Abraham and David were justified by faith, and because justification rests on a promise, it is guaranteed and open to everyone who believes.
In chapter 5, because we've been justified by faith, we have reason to rejoice in the hope of the glory of God, and that hope is guaranteed because God loves us.
Chapter 6 begins a new section, where Paul takes objections to his gospel. The first objection was that his gospel implies we should keep sinning to glorify God. Paul says no: part of the gift is saving us from our sinfulness, so pursuing sin would make a mockery of the gift. The second objection was that without the law as a threat, there's no reason not to sin. Paul says there is still a consequence, and that is death: the bitterness, frustration, brokenness, loneliness, and sharp tongues that make our lives weary and draining.
Then in Romans 7:1–6 he says the law was never an incentive anyway. He uses an analogy from marriage. The marriage law binds a woman to her husband for life. If her husband dies, that law no longer binds her, and she is free to form a new relationship. In the same way, the law bound us to our flesh, and by flesh Paul means everything we are apart from God, all our self-effort. Since we died to sin in Christ, we are no longer bound to that law, and we're free for a new relationship with God. Under the law we had no resources but our own sinfulness, so all the law did was arouse our sin. The harder we tried, the more we saw we couldn't do it. Under grace, God imparts his Spirit to write the law on our hearts so that we can fulfill it, in part now, and completely in heaven.
Is the Law Evil?
That raises the next question. "Paul, if the law just promotes our sin, then the law must be a bad thing. But God gave us the law. So either God is bad, or your gospel is wrong."
Paul's answer is no. The law is a good thing because it alerts us to our sinfulness, and that's a great blessing. The law accomplishes two things. It clarifies what's true, that we're sinful, and it intensifies our awareness of it so we can't escape it. That's what God designed it to do. That's essentially the whole chapter.
As a Bible study note, watch how Paul uses the word "law" in this chapter. Early on he means the Mosaic law, the written code. By verse 21, when he talks about "the law of sin," he means a principle or force of sin, not a written code.
What then shall we say? That the law is sin? By no means! Yet if it had not been for the law, I would not have known sin. For I would not have known what it is to covet if the law had not said, "You shall not covet." But sin, seizing an opportunity through the commandment, produced in me all kinds of covetousness. For apart from the law, sin lies dead. I was once alive apart from the law, but when the commandment came, sin came alive and I died. The very commandment that promised life proved to be death to me. For sin, seizing an opportunity through the commandment, deceived me and through it killed me. So the law is holy, and the commandment is holy and righteous and good. Did that which is good, then, bring death to me? By no means! It was sin, producing death in me through what is good, in order that sin might be shown to be sin. -- Romans 7:7–13
Coveting and Sin
Paul highlights the tenth commandment because it's different than the others. You could obey the first nine outwardly and think you were doing pretty well. But the tenth is clearly an inward thing. Coveting is wanting something you don't have, greedily longing for what isn't yours, resenting people who have more than you do. You can be very religious on the outside and covet on the inside, and no one will know.
As a Pharisee, Paul would have studied the law, defined its nuances, and debated its finer points. He says in Philippians that he did a pretty good job of keeping it outwardly. Then he comes to the tenth commandment, which says you're not even supposed to want to sin. Now he knows he has a problem.
When he says he would not have known sin apart from the law, he doesn't mean he had a laundry list and finally figured out that coveting belonged in the "wrong" column. He means he wouldn't have understood that something in him was beyond his control, a principle of sin deeply embedded in him that he couldn't change.
Let me give you an analogy. Suppose you have cancer and you don't know it. You get up in the morning, your throat's a little dry, you cough a little, and you think it's okay, get a cup of coffee and go. You notice a spot on your arm and think you were just out in the sun. You carry on assuming you're healthy.
Then you're diagnosed. Now when your throat is dry, you immediately think, it's pneumonia, it's something horrible. You start measuring every cough and every ache, and despair begins to fill your life. You see the spot on your arm and think, I'm sure I'm dying now. The fact is you're no more or less healthy than before. But now you know.
That's what Paul is saying. He was just as sinful before the law as after, but now he knows. The law is our diagnosis. It holds up a mirror and says, you've got this disease of sin.
Another analogy: imagine you and your small group are on a river rafting trip, floating down the river without any oars. It's a sunny day, the birds are singing, there's a light breeze, and everyone is having a great time, except the one person who looked at the map. They know that around the corner is a waterfall. For everyone else it's a lovely day. For that one person, it's a tragedy.
When Paul says, "I was once alive apart from the law, but when the commandment came, sin came alive and I died," he means he has looked at the map. Before the law he was morally naive. He thought he was fine, happy, going to live forever. The law shook him awake and told him he was living under a death sentence. That's what he means by "sin came alive."
It's important to note what kind of rebellion he's describing. It's not the child who looks at you when you say "Don't cross that line" and crosses it anyway. It's the rebellion of a child who sincerely wants to obey and finds he can't. Paul agreed with the law and loved it, but he couldn't keep it. It's more like a smoker who finds out he's addicted. No matter how much you resolve, no matter how much willpower you muster, you still sin.
So in verse 12 he concludes that the law is holy and righteous and good. It did him an incredible favor. Without it he would not have known the depth of his sinfulness and his need for a savior. Then the follow-up: did this good thing become a source of death for me? No. What condemns me is my sin. The law just reveals my situation so I know where I'm headed. I was sinful before the law came. The law doesn't condemn me. I condemn myself.
The Present-Tense Struggle
Notice that in verse 14 the tense changes. Now Paul speaks in the present tense, which I find very comforting.
For we know that the law is spiritual, but I am of the flesh, sold under sin. For I do not understand my own actions. For I do not do what I want, but I do the very thing I hate. Now if I do what I do not want, I agree with the law, that it is good. So now it is no longer I who do it, but sin that dwells within me. For I know that nothing good dwells in me, that is, in my flesh. For I have the desire to do what is right, but not the ability to carry it out. For I do not do the good I want, but the evil I do not want is what I keep on doing. Now if I do what I do not want, it is no longer I who do it, but sin that dwells within me. So I find it to be a law that when I want to do right, evil lies close at hand. For I delight in the law of God, in my inner being, but I see in my members another law waging war against the law of my mind and making me captive to the law of sin that dwells in my members. Wretched man that I am! Who will deliver me from this body of death? -- Romans 7:14–24
Again, by "flesh" I don't think Paul means our bodies specifically, but everything we are apart from God.
Let me go back to his marriage analogy. Imagine a woman who was married to an abusive man. He dies, and she marries a new man who is wonderful, loving, kind, and good. She is deeply committed to him and wants to honor him, but she still has a problem. She has all these memories and reactions and training from her old husband. When her new husband gives her a gift, instead of thinking he did it because he loves her, she thinks, what's the catch? I must have done something wrong. She reacts to him the way she reacted to the first husband who humiliated her, lied to her, and twisted everything positive into something negative. She may even lie to or deceive her new husband when he's done nothing to deserve it. She hates it, but she can't stop.
That's the situation Paul is describing. Having died with Christ, we have a new love and a new law we want to keep, but we can't. "I have the desire to do what is right, but not the ability to carry it out." That is our lot this side of heaven.
The distinction between "I" and "sin that dwells within me" isn't some theological entity. It's the distinction between my desire and my ability. And this is not a "the devil made me do it" approach. Paul isn't shifting responsibility or claiming to be a victim, because he concludes, "Wretched man that I am!" He accepts full responsibility. He knows he's in trouble. No matter how much he resolves not to sin, he still sins.
Picture a cheap made-for-TV movie where a plane is headed for a mountain. The flight controllers say, "You've got to do something!" The pilot says, "Don't worry, I've got it under control. All I have to do is turn this little stick." Then he gets close to the mountain, turns the stick, and finds out it doesn't work. The only way he knows how to fly doesn't work. That's Paul. He loves the law and wants to keep it, but he can't. The problem is not ignorance or lack of willpower. The problem is that he's sinful.
We know why from chapter 1. Remember my analogy of the two hands back to back: God abandoned us to sin and death and made us its prisoners. God is the only source of life and righteousness, and under the law he isn't granting it. The problem of his wrath has to be solved before the problem of our sin can be.
Paul's point is that sin is, in a sense, beyond our control. It would not surprise me if we found out sin is genetic. Our society says that if I didn't choose it, it's not wrong. If I'm an alcoholic because of my genes or the way I was raised, it's not wrong. I think Paul's theology would say you don't have a choice over any of your sins. We can't just decide to stop being angry or lustful or selfish or vain. Apart from the grace of God, we can decide all we want and we won't get anywhere.
So he cries out, "Who will deliver me?" and answers, "Thanks be to God through Jesus Christ our Lord! So then, I myself serve the law of God with my mind, but with my flesh I serve the law of sin." God is going to solve this problem by working at a level that changes who we are, so that we can begin to keep the law. I think Paul gets so excited he can't hold it back, because he doesn't really answer the question until chapter 8. All of chapter 8 is the answer.
Free Will and Election
This passage raises a question that keeps coming up: if I have the desire but not the ability, how can God condemn me? If I'm not capable of being righteous, how do I have any free will at all?
Let me warn you, I'm not going to answer all your questions. I'm not arrogant enough to think that after 2,000 years I'm the first person to figure this out. Smarter minds than mine are still debating it. Different people and different denominations untangle it in different ways, and I don't expect you to agree with all of this. But it makes sense to me given what I know of the Bible, and it goes a long way toward solving the problem for me.
Here's the paradox. The Bible teaches that God is completely sovereign, that he saves us and chooses us, and yet we're morally accountable for our disobedience. How can both be true?
The model most people try to live with puts the two side by side. Under divine sovereignty, God determines my choices and my salvation. Under human responsibility, I determine my choices and choose God. The implications contradict each other. Under sovereignty, I'm not responsible for my sinful choices, I can't hinder God's grace, my inheritance is certain, and I can't work for my sanctification because it's up to God. Under human responsibility, I am responsible for my choices, I can hinder God's grace, and my inheritance isn't certain because I have to work at my sanctification.
The problem is that you can't live a contradiction. When I go out tomorrow and make choices, I have to act as if either God is in control or I am. Nobody can live both ways, so we end up picking one. In the Reformed tradition, we lean toward divine sovereignty. Other traditions lean toward human responsibility. So how do we affirm both? Here's my best attempt. I'd call it a step toward a solution, not the full solution.
Free Will Is Uncoerced but Not Undetermined
The key, I think, is what we mean by free will. I want to suggest that free will is uncoerced but not undetermined.
If I came up to my friend Libby, held a gun to her head, and said, "Libby, you want to go shopping with me today, don't you?" she would say, "Of course, Krisan, I'd love to." None of us would call that a free choice. I coerced her. Some outside force made her choose something she would not normally choose. We tend to think God coerces us, and therefore we're not free. But God never coerces us to do anything. It's a false dichotomy to say we're either coerced or free. There's another option: a determined choice, one that is predicted by my nature.
If you ask me whether I like asparagus, I'll say no. I hate asparagus. I always have, and I probably always will, and I don't know why. When I was growing up, my mom would hide it in casseroles and soups, convinced it was a childish thing I'd outgrow, and I would always find it. The first bite, I'd say, "Does this have asparagus in it?" My husband, on the other hand, loves it. When we go to fancy restaurants that serve asparagus, he gets a double portion, because he gets mine too. I'm sure it's a defective taste bud or something.
What determines that choice? It's just who I am. All your choices are determined by something: your biology, your experience, the way you were raised, your body chemistry, your genetics, your social conditioning, your cultural background, your emotional state at the time. If I ask Libby to go shopping, she isn't choosing in a vacuum. Whether she says yes depends on who she is, whether she has money, whether she likes being around me. Whether you're a morning person or a night person, whether you like sports or music or gardening, all the things that make you you determine how you will choose in any situation.
I'm going to call that your nature, and now you see where I'm headed. When you choose, you choose in accordance with your nature. I have freely, uncoercedly chosen to avoid asparagus, but not in a vacuum. My free will is uncoerced, but it is determined by my nature. And my nature is sinful. So when I choose, I will choose sinful things. No one is holding a gun to my head or twisting my arm. I've chosen on the basis of who I am.
What God does is change our natures. He works at that deeper level so that now, when I have a choice, I choose differently. Maybe in heaven I'll even like asparagus. I doubt it. Hopefully it won't exist in heaven.
When our kids were little, we used to tell them they had broken choosers. The thing inside them that made them choose good or bad was broken, and no matter how hard they resolved to choose right, left to themselves they couldn't choose otherwise. That's the toddler-theology way of saying I have a sinful nature. God works at the deepest level of whatever makes me me, and he fixes my broken chooser.
The first thing he fixes is our desire. Now we want righteousness. We hunger and thirst for it. But in his grace and his purposes, he doesn't fix the ability as quickly as he fixes the desire. So we're stuck in the Romans 7 problem: I want to do right, but I lack the ability. Insofar as God has changed me, I will make those choices. Insofar as he has not changed me yet, I will still choose sin. God isn't forcing me to choose against my nature. He changes me at the very level of who I am.
Putting Sovereignty and Responsibility Together
If I put this all together, it goes like this. My choices are determined within my will by my nature. Insofar as I am sinful, I will choose sin. Insofar as God has changed me, I will not. My nature is sinful, and left to myself I cannot change it. I am a prisoner of sin and death unless God rescues me.
And God is not obligated to change my nature. I think that's the point we miss, and to me it's the key to the puzzle. I can't change my nature. God can, but he's not required to. There's nothing I do that forces him to save me, no divine spark in me that obligates him. Even faith itself is a gift from God. God ultimately determines my salvation as an act of grace.
The implications are these. I am responsible for my sinful choices, because I am a sinful person and I choose them because that's who I am. But if I have saving faith in Jesus, my sins are covered by grace. I cannot hinder God's grace, because it's part of the gift. God has chosen, for whatever reasons, to save me, and I can't stop him. That's what we learned in chapter 5. My inheritance is certain because it is a gift of God. And sanctification is the result of God changing my nature, which means my obedience is the fruit of God's work in my life, not the root of it. Insofar as I am obedient, I can say, thanks be to God. But my good works are not the requirement that makes God change me. They're the result of his changing me.
There's one more question this raises: how can God hold us accountable for being sinful if we were born that way? Paul answers that in chapter 9, and I'll warn you now, you're not going to like the answer.
Questions
Why doesn't God just change us right now? Someone asked: if God wants me to be righteous and good, why am I still here sinning? I can't answer all of that, but I think I can get to part of it. I think God's primary agenda in this life is to make us people of faith, not completely righteous people. His goal is to make us mature and trusting, not necessarily perfectly obedient. That's coming in the next life. So he may let us continue in a sin because that's the tool he's using to rub off our rough edges, to keep us on our knees so we don't get arrogant and think we did this on our own. He's not leaving us in our sin to be cruel. He's displaying his graciousness and goodness and working on our characters to make us more faithful.
How can we be rewarded if God is the one changing us? Think about what we're getting versus what we're doing. If I tell my son, "If you take out the trash, I'll give you a million dollars," and he does it and I give him a million dollars, can you really say he earned it? What I gave him is so out of proportion to what he did. God's grace is the million dollars, and our part is taking out the trash. It's a reward, but not one we earned in any sense of the word. I think what God wants most is for us to be grateful. The response isn't "Why don't you make it easier?" It's "Thank you for saving me at all." Why does it have to be so hard? I don't know. I would like it to be easier, and I'm sure everybody else would too. That's where we come back to the passages where he says, "My ways are not your ways, and my thoughts are not your thoughts." He has demonstrated such incredible love that we can trust he knows what he's doing, even when we don't.
Is Paul describing his life before he became a Christian? Some people read Romans 7 as Paul's pre-Christian experience, or as believers who were born of the Spirit but not yet indwelt by the Spirit before Pentecost, with the answer coming in chapter 8. My problem with that view is that after receiving the Spirit, we still have the struggle. If we took a vote, everyone in the room would say so. Either none of us has received the Spirit, or Paul means something else. And the question I'd love to ask the people who hold that view is: how do I get the Spirit to indwell me? If it's something I have to do, what happened to the first five chapters of Romans? Paul is clear that all of this is a gift of God. If God's gift goes only so far and then I have to do something to reach the next step, sanctification is back on my shoulders, and I don't think Romans teaches that. I don't think you can get that from Ephesians, Galatians, or 1 John either. That's why there are so many commentaries on Romans, and they don't all agree.
I know this is a sticky wicket, but it's so much fun to talk about.
Next: 11 Why Trying Harder Can't Make You Holy (Romans 8:1-11)
Previous: 09 If We Can't Lose Grace, Why Not Sin? (Romans 6:15-7:6)
Series: Romans: Justification by Faith
Study: Romans Resources
AI-generated image created by the author.
Season 2, Episode 10
Page Views: 1,659